News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by hef19898 on Friday September 21, 2018 @06:23AM (#18038587)
If you don't mind asking, what kind of actual use cases do you see in the supply chain environment for blockchain? I would assume the financa part would be more suitable, but up to now I didn't find a use case where I personally see the benefit. As I assume I might miss something it would be great to hear your opinion on it.
Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by Silixon on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:11AM (#18038800)
As an example, food safety in the developing world. Food firms claim food is fresh and came from places where it did not come from. If you introduce an agricultural and food tagging system that logs food item IDs into a blockchain-based system, you can know when and where food was made and grown.

Note that this ignores the huge expense of measuring and storing all of this data, but I've seen some interest in these use cases in Asia, especially for staple crops like rice.

Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by Marazan on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:27AM (#18038875)
How does that in anyway protect against fraud?
Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by Silixon on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:49AM (#18038980)
You don't take the data at face value. The goal of these systems is to reduce human intervention, not to remove the intervention. If a firm fakes data, you still have proof in the bad products and customer complaints. This lets you investigate and file complaints on the public blockchain. Think of it like a review of a company's supply chain reliability.

More advanced systems consider using third party, tamper proof scanning systems and packaging. Again, the costs of these systems are quite high, especially for food, but there are physical ways to reduce fraud if the data holds enough value.

Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by staticvar on Friday September 21, 2018 @01:33PM (#18041279)
> If a firm fakes data, you still have proof in the bad products and customer complaints.

Someone who fakes products can read the blockchain and print fake labels based on what is there.

> This lets you investigate and file complaints on the public blockchain. Think of it like a review of a company's supply chain reliability.

So the blockchain in this case is used as company review database? How is a blockchain useful for that?

Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by Silixon on Friday September 21, 2018 @09:12PM (#18043913)
They can always print fake labels, but they can't deliver fake products too many times. Customers will realize that fraud is happening. Again, there are also ways to make labels that cannot be faked, then attach those labels to tamper-proof packaging. It helps to realize that these labels and packaging exist so that the food items can be scanned and tracked as they enter and leave different facilities along the supply chain.

A blockchain is useful as a review database because you have guarantees that the reviews came from the claimed reviewer. This reduces fake claim fraud, which you might, for example, see in restaurant reviews. The reputation of the purchasing company is also at stake when they make claims that another company committed fraud. You want good guarantees that information came from the party it's ascribed to. It's reputation building in a scenario without mutual trust.

Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by askmike on Friday September 21, 2018 @06:40AM (#18038661)
Hard to say for me, because the obstacles and problems in these projects are always legal and business. I'm just an engineer ;)

> use case where I personally see the benefit

This is just infrastructure (as it should be), right now the middlemen are very expensive because of all the paper documents going between companies, and all the people hired to go over all of them. The usual arguments for these projects are:

- Cheaper

- Quicker decision making & communication

- Less fraud & errors

For us consumers that would probably result in cheaper apples in the the grocery store I guess.

Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by hef19898 on Friday September 21, 2018 @06:49AM (#18038700)
Thanks for the quick answer! So it would be fair to say to get rid of the paper work by making it digital and using blockchain to reduce the fraud risk?

Anyway, I'm really curious to see what people come up with! And yes, being faster and cheaper is summing up logisitcs pretty well! ;-)

Re:The Private Blockchain Fallacy by askmike on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:53AM (#18038994)
> So it would be fair to say to get rid of the paper work by making it digital and using blockchain to reduce the fraud risk?

I'm no expert on fraud, but I think most of it comes when data enters a system. With a blockchain (or any digital system really) you can easily check that your data stays consistent (when it needs to be between different documents and contracts). But if the guy entering how many tons of apple are in this container is lying about it a blockchain won't really help you.