News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by Secretmapper on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:24AM (#18038067)
Looks like the AI is just playing against Starcraft II's AI, which makes this slightly less impressive, as I first thought it was against human players.

The SC2 AI on higher difficulties does cheat though (extra resources) so it does make it slightly impressive, but still a far cry from human opponents as SC2's AI is pretty easy to beat (it would be around Gold in ladder I think)

Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by Strilanc on Friday September 21, 2018 @04:43AM (#18038143)
If it's just the built-in AIs, you're right that it's much less impressive. They should be winning 100% of the time.

For example, I don't know if they've fixed this, but you used to be able to beat the AIs 1v4 on the highest difficulty. There was a bug where the AIs would surrender individually even though they were on a team. So with an all-out rush you could get two of them to surrender almost immediately by running 2-3 zealots through their mineral lines. Getting the third one to surrender required a bit more fighting, and then the fourth was more of a normal game.

The AIs also used to keep their entire army in one big death ball, and if there were 3-4 fighting units in their base they would send the army home to defend. Even if their army was 10x bigger than yours and they'd win the base race. So you could hop reapers into and out of their bases to prevent them from attacking your base indefinitely (because they kept running home). Also you were doing pretty serious damage with the reapers while they ran back.

Another exploit was to start building a cheap building in their base area at the start, somewhat far away from the mining line. They would send a ridiculous number of workers to attack your building. So they'd lose significantly more money to lack-of-mining than you did for building and cancelling a pylon or whatever.

Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by snarfy on Friday September 21, 2018 @06:33AM (#18038626)
If you float an overlord just out of range, sometimes their entire army will just sit their watching it. I've accidentally won many vs AI games this way. There also some 1 base all-in's that I've never had the AI defend.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by swarnie_ on Friday September 21, 2018 @05:15AM (#18038300)
> Another exploit was to start building a cheap building in their base area at the start, somewhat far away from the mining line. They would send a ridiculous number of workers to attack your building. So they'd lose significantly more money to lack-of-mining than you did for building and cancelling a pylon or whatever.

Similar to this none of the inbuilt AI's can deal with a slow cannon rush. They will hesitate for ages then rush 5 finished cannons.

The later Ai's do a little scv tanking and kiting but nothing near enough, they don't even focus down the probes.

Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by qubax on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:55AM (#18039002)
> If it's just the built-in AIs, you're right that it's much less impressive. They should be winning 100% of the time.

Absolutely. Unless the win-loss ratio includes all games while the AI "learns" to play the game. It might have lost most of its early games, but now wins 100% of the time.

I suspect it wouldn't take DeepMind long to master starcraft II and beat starcraft's AI 100% of the time.

Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by sct202 on Friday September 21, 2018 @10:23AM (#18039882)
It also reacts very badly to liberators zones, compared to like tank zones.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by henryw on Friday September 21, 2018 @01:48PM (#18041393)
Vs 4 insane AIs, I floated my command center to an island with 2 mineral patches and produced mass battlecruisers =D
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by thomasahle on Friday September 21, 2018 @08:07AM (#18039061)
> it would be around Gold in ladder I think

In the article, they say it plays around Platinium / low Diamond, when they had it play on the ladder.

Though also: "It is worth noting that although TStarBot1 can successfully learn and acquire strategies to defeat all the builtin AIs and TStarBot2, it lacks strategy diversity in order to consistently beat human players. In the aforementioned test with human players, TStarBot1 will be unable to win once the human player starts to know TStarBot1’s preference for Zergling Rush."

Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by 36bydesign on Friday September 21, 2018 @05:52AM (#18038450)
It would be bronze. The built in AI is much worse than you think.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by cjbprime on Friday September 21, 2018 @10:47AM (#18040066)
Can confirm, beat all of the AI levels reliably before moving to ladder, and placed in bronze and stayed there for a few months.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by tudelo on Friday September 21, 2018 @09:36AM (#18039557)
This is not true. Maybe when the game first came out, but average skill level has decreased greatly.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by cjbprime on Friday September 21, 2018 @10:46AM (#18040054)
This is counter to the current perception of professional players, which is that world champions from ten years ago played the way that unexceptional ladder players play today. I think the average skill level has been increasing monotonically over time.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by tudelo on Friday September 21, 2018 @06:44PM (#18043233)
Fine, overall skill has increased. But given the vast amount of information and strategy guides, it is much easier to get to a diamond level now than it was before.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by cjbprime on Friday September 21, 2018 @10:22PM (#18044116)
That idea doesn't seem coherent to me -- Diamond is just another way to say "top 60-90th percentile". The vast amount of information is available to everyone equally, so it doesn't explain why some people are above average players. Players in every league have improved. There's no static "diamond level" way of playing that's been unchanged over ten years to compare against.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by 36bydesign on Friday September 21, 2018 @01:07PM (#18041097)
I’ve played since the release date thru now with gaps of time not playing... from my experience it’s unequivocally clear that the skill level is much much higher than when the game first came out. Like not even close.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by arnaudsm on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:50PM (#18043534)
That's true. Watching the first WCS championship is extremely cringy even for a normal-skilled player today. It's cool to see how the meta has improved in recent years !
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by emodendroket on Friday September 21, 2018 @02:39PM (#18041734)
If true that would make it pretty much alone along long-running competitive games.
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by psandersen on Friday September 21, 2018 @01:57PM (#18041454)
You mean average skill has increased?
Re:Tencent's AI plays StarCraft II, and wins over 90 percent... by __s on Friday September 21, 2018 @07:43AM (#18038943)
Bronze is now the bottom 4 percentile. I was around the level of Very Hard while 2600 NAMMR (High silver)