TOTP/HOTP can still be sort of trivially MITM'd - a phishing form could ask for your auth code and then turn around and supply it to the site in question.
U2F uses a challenge-response protocol that should (in theory) make it impossible to MITM. Google has said that they have had zero successful phishing attacks since they switched to using U2F devices (I think Yubikeys) for all employees.
Re:Introducing the Librem Key
by confounded on Thursday September 20, 2018 @01:38PM
(#18034178)
You could still use the TOTP Heads validation method with a phone (currently how it works on Librem laptops with a TPM).
I agree. I would rather use my phone then a separate hardware device especially since I use a lot of computers. I might look into something like this https://krypt.co/
- I often log in to web services on my phone, and I don't have an usb adapter cable with me to use the key, and
- because having to carry a device always with me sounds cumbersome. My phone is always with me anyways.
Is there some other use case I am overlooking? I am eagerly awaiting browser vendors to implement these use cases: https://w3c.github.io/webauthn/#use-cases