News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by darawk on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @11:41AM (#18025014)
I'm not sure what your point is here: "Sometimes people lie or obfuscate...therefore let's not bother with the truth" ?
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by bildung on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:06PM (#18025728)
More like: "In a political context gathering data is not at all a guaranteed way to get further to the truth."

I don't want to make a case for dismissing an empirical approach per se!

An current example from Germany right now: There's a part of the country that's in uproar because of new immigrants that came in 2015. Some people felt threatened and demanded more police in public spaces were immigrant youth gathers. So more police is present at those public spaces. Naturally this resulted in them being aware of more violent events (mostly groups of immigrant kids scuffling), which made the immigrant share of violent crimes double, and people feel "rightfully" afraid, as the stats now proof their suspicions! But the reality of course is that German kids have fights in public, too; police just didn't take note and so those fights don't end up in the data gathered.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by darawk on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @02:08PM (#18026326)
> More like: "In a political context gathering data is not at all a guaranteed way to get further to the truth."

It's not guaranteed, no. But it's the only way we have any hope of it.

> An current example from Germany right now: There's a part of the country that's in uproar because of new immigrants that came in 2015. Some people felt threatened and demanded more police in public spaces were immigrant youth gathers. So more police is present at those public spaces. Naturally this resulted in them being aware of more violent events (mostly groups of immigrant kids scuffling), which made the immigrant share of violent crimes double, and people feel "rightfully" afraid, as the stats now proof their suspicions! But the reality of course is that German kids have fights in public, too; police just didn't take note and so those fights don't end up in the data gathered.

Is that actually true, though? I'm not familiar with the figures, but it's not unreasonable to imagine there may genuinely be more violent incidents among migrants from a war torn region like that. There were certainly serious cultural assimilation problems:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Year%27s_Eve_sexual_assaul...

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by 08-15 on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @06:11PM (#18028070)
> But the reality of course is that German kids have fights in public, too

Not deadly knife fights, though. We don't want to erase the difference between brutal murder (25 stab wounds) and "a scuffle", do we?

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by bildung on Thursday September 20, 2018 @03:27AM (#18030417)
Well, this isn't about murder. Murder rates didn't raise, but statistics for scuffles did. In both cases this is about crimes among immigrants, though, not about crimes of immigrants against Germans.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by 08-15 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @07:28AM (#18031411)
> In both cases this is about crimes among immigrants, though

Does that make it less of a problem?

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by bildung on Friday September 21, 2018 @05:08AM (#18038268)
Yes, as the entire point of this thread is problematic application of data in a political context. The data is violent crime stats. The false interpretation is fear of the native polulation. The native population is not affected by the violence, ergo the fear is misplaced.

That you brought up the murder in the first place is exactly the misuse of statistics I spoke of. About 400 people get murdered every year in Germany, and you bring up exactly the one recent case were the suspects are immigrants.