News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by luckydata on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @10:24PM (#18021171)
Coming from the Chicago School of Economics, specialized in voodoo theories that don't pan out in the real world this is pretty funny.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by refurb on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @10:50AM (#18024547)
Compared to what? Other economic schools of theory that worked out exactly as predicted?
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @10:37PM (#18021233)
Pretty much. The Chicago school was the one pushing for financial deregulation, IIRC.

I think the problem here is that we elect governments to solve collective problems, not personal problems. Collective problems arise from the interactions of large groups of people and they are generally intractable. Even if an economist tries to accurately model human behavior, it's really hard to do as you start adding more rational agents, and then you need a theory of production and a theory of expectations formation and all of a sudden what you are doing is just a toy to be tractable.

So the zone where there is clear unambiguous science is very small, and it's generally not the zone of contention in politics. Stuff like "don't swallow arsenic" -- it doesn't really help us to govern or solve any of our political questions.

So if we can't use science to show us how to organize ourselves, the debate turns to meta-approaches which are basically philosophies of how we approach problems.

For example, a liberal might start with a Rousseau-type blank slate view of human nature and a various declaration of rights, both of which are basically statements of faith, and then try to think of some way that government can secure those rights through a period of debate, and then adopt whatever seems right to the people doing the debating, even if it means overturning long established customs.

A conservative might go -- woah, there is hidden information in customs and traditions, which we may not appreciate (it's hidden) but, as an article of faith, the fact that these customs have lasted so long means that they are probably useful for _something_, and I doubt your ability to think of every unintended consequence of your policy, so I'm going to oppose it, and instead suggest you do something much smaller, as a pilot, over here for a generation, and then see what happens.

And a libertarian might be led to say, "Your proposal infringes on my personal liberties, and thus, as an article of faith, must lead to bad outcomes."

Etc.

So the real debates we have are actually methodological debates given that we are working under imperfect information and limited knowledge about how complex interacting social systems work. Saying "we should use more science" is vacuous B.S. What we need is a better functioning public policy discourse that supports more course corrections, allows more people to air their views, and eliminates certain known distortions, like the influence of big money groups on campaigns. That's a hell of a lot more useful than pretending that scientists can be politicians or that politicians should be scientists.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by yesenadam on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:12AM (#18021613)
Well, outside of Oakeshott (Rationalism in Politics) I've not heard a conservative talk like that, but great comment.

A story from Chesterton's Heretics (1905):

Suppose that a great commotion arises in the street about something, let us say a lamp-post, which many influential persons desire to pull down. A grey-clad monk, who is the spirit of the Middle Ages, is approached upon the matter, and begins to say, in the arid manner of the Schoolmen, “Let us first of all consider, my brethren, the value of Light. If Light be in itself good–” At this point he is somewhat excusably knocked down. All the people make a rush for the lamp-post, the lamp-post is down in ten minutes, and they go about congratulating each other on their unmediaeval practicality. But as things go on they do not work out so easily. Some people have pulled the lamp-post down because they wanted the electric light; some because they wanted old iron; some because they wanted darkness, because their deeds were evil. Some thought it not enough of a lamp-post, some too much; some acted because they wanted to smash municipal machinery; some because they wanted to smash something. And there is war in the night, no man knowing whom he strikes. So, gradually and inevitably, to-day, to-morrow, or the next day, there comes back the conviction that the monk was right after all, and that all depends on what is the philosophy of Light. Only what we might have discussed under the gas-lamp, we now must discuss in the dark.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:25AM (#18021663)
I think most conservatives defer to and value tradition and customs because they feel this, even though they may not articulate it in the same way. Roger Scruton gives a nice summary, in his book on conservatism: https://www.amazon.com/Conservatism-Invitation-Tradition-Rog...

Similarly liberals who say things like "all men are created equal and have the same rights and can institute whatever practices seem right to them" may not know anything about Rousseau and blank slates, but they are expressing these views.

Thanks for the Chesterton quote. Chesterton is awesome. A bit of a lunatic, but also insightful and fun to read.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by darawk on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @03:56AM (#18022573)
> So the zone where there is clear unambiguous science is very small, and it's generally not the zone of contention in politics. Stuff like "don't swallow arsenic" -- it doesn't really help us to govern or solve any of our political questions.

So, what, we should just make things up? Do you have some other decision procedure aside from the scientific method you would like to employ?

> What we need is a better functioning public policy discourse that supports more course corrections, allows more people to air their views, and eliminates certain known distortions, like the influence of big money groups on campaigns. That's a hell of a lot more useful than pretending that scientists can be politicians or that politicians should be scientists.

And what is going to inform that public policy discourse? Are we just going to talk at each other about our prior beliefs and implicit biases until one side gets tired? Or should we use the scientific method to answer empirical questions about the impacts of policy, and then debate which values we should use the knowledge gleaned therefrom to optimize? I know which one i'd prefer.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by maxxxxx on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @11:57PM (#18021564)
I agree that a lot of policy decision are value judgements and can't be fully explained by scientific approaches.

But I definitely would like to see more hard numbers in political discourse. For example, what was the effect of previous tax cuts that increased deficits? Just put out the numbers: government revenue, business investment and so on. At least people (maybe) could have a rational foundation for their opinions. But I guess I am asking too much...

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:34AM (#18021689)
I was horrified at the business tax cuts that we recently passed, and I was sure they wouldn't result in any real benefits for investment.

But, to me, that's more of an example of money in politics and money having a big loudspeaker rather than "more science needed".

Moreover, I don't think that people who voted for Trump, voted for him because they favored corporate tax cuts, but I think it was more of a protest vote.

Of course, I could be wrong, but the problem is the outsized influence of lobbyists and the wealthy in our political system -- that was a Koch brothers job. I don't think conservatives love the Koch brothers, to be honest.

Let's remember "science" was how the economists pushed through all the banking de-regulation and liberalization of international capital flows which I am so opposed to, as well as other disastrous reforms. For example, the sadism against Greece in the EU was led by PhDs, and many PhDs pushed for more austerity.

So, for me, "more science" isn't the solution, but something like public financing of campaigns might be a better solution. I think the skepticism of technocrats is quite healthy.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by maxxxxx on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:43AM (#18021724)
I guess I would like to see more data and less opinion. Especially in economics.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by Rainymood on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:38AM (#18021957)
Your comment shows a severe lack of knowledge what economics research is all about, please correct me if I'm wrong.

I have two graduate degrees (econometrics) and while I understand and can reason with most of these models I'd argue exactly the opposite. Economics is not a "real science" or rather, it is the science of humans, and we know for sure that humans are fickle and irrational.

Economics is not a hard science yet sometimes is treated as such, and this research is then taken true as gospel (which I argue is wrong). There is a lot of things wrong with economics (I'm a fan of behavioral economics in particular) but "I want to see more data" is a non-argument. You're acting like economists are some armchair scientists waving around wet fingers in the air.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by darawk on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @04:03AM (#18022608)
This sort of radical skepticism is generally unhelpful. It is simply not the case that the economics literature, on the whole, conveys no information. It conveys quite a bit, and often correctly answers a myriad of serious, useful, practical political questions. There are certainly edge cases that get a lot of attention upon which the data and consensus are split (e.g. minimum wage disemployment effects), but using those edge cases to disregard the research of an entire field (in favor of what, anyway?) is profoundly misguided.

Economic decisions have to be made by politicians. That is an unavoidable fact. They can either attempt to use the best data available to optimize the values that they care about...or they can just do whatever they feel is best, informed by, what? Their gut? Their down home common sense?

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:12AM (#18021828)
Me, too, but especially in an area like economics, the rich are going to fund studies and be able to dominate the profession, so "more data" is tricky. I guess I am just asking for better economics that had a better track record in out of sample predictions, but that's wishful thinking in any social science.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by msla on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:34PM (#18025445)
> So the zone where there is clear unambiguous science is very small, and it's generally not the zone of contention in politics.

Unless it's climate science, reproductive health, evolutionary biology, the existence of "electromagnetic hypersensitivity", whether fracking causes earthquakes, or a list of other topics where denialism and, yes, outright lying have arisen to challenge science that the scientific community regards as unambiguously settled.

Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by raihansaputra on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @12:35AM (#18021698)
I don't know whether you've also read these books or not, but for others who are really interested in this, I can't recommend Anti-Fragile and Skin In The Game by Taleb that explores this view and topic. I just finished them both and I feel the book can explain it in a reasonable way, but don't get too serious on his name-calling. It gets a bit funny when you know where he comes from.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by rsj_hn on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @01:15AM (#18021844)
I know of Taleb, but haven't read him. I've read some of his essays, and he has good points to make. The name calling doesn't bother me (since he hasn't gored one of my sacred cows, not because I am especially enlightened)
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by raihansaputra on Wednesday September 19, 2018 @05:28AM (#18022960)
typo: I meant I can't recommend them enough to have more understanding about this topic.
Re:Want more policies based on evidence? by fein on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @11:05PM (#18021350)
We need more people like yourself sowing discourse on HN.

Good read, and great take on the current stream of consciousness.