Re:Ask HN: Necessary piracy?
by andrewljohnson on Sunday October 17, 2010 @08:18PM
(#1801837)
That's the thing... I'm pretty sure we can open source all of our code, and it will be business as usual.
We already open source a lot of stuff, because that stuff alone isn't nearly enough to beat us.
Re:Ask HN: Necessary piracy?
by bendmorris on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:16PM
(#1804033)
"I'm pretty sure we can open source all of our code, and it will be business as usual."
For everyone working on something trivial, which is most people, you're right. I don't think it would really work for important complex algorithms, etc., i.e., Google is not going to open source their search algorithm.
It sounds like you're saying that Google, after coming up with their version of search, should've just opened it up to the world, because everyone has the "right" to know what they're up to. Do you think they'd be in the same position today if they'd done that?
Re:Ask HN: Necessary piracy?
by andrewljohnson on Monday October 18, 2010 @11:09PM
(#1806055)
Google's main search algorithms are well-known and essentially open. It's all the little bits they keep adding on that are unknown.
That software you're working on is just a unique configuration of words and symbols. I think there's value in protecting that, and I don't see any difference in regards to written publications.