Re:LDL-C Does Not Cause Cardiovascular Disease: A Comprehens...
by et2o on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @10:45AM
(#18015756)
Could be a number of reasons:
1) Bad stuff sneaks in everywhere if you get lucky with two reviewers and an editor asleep at the wheel. Even good journals. Not usually this bad, though.
2) This isn't a particularly good journal and isn't a cardiovascular journal, so they probably got two reviewers who are not knowledgeable about the field.
3) It might also have been an invited paper. These medoum-low journals often solicit reviews, and it's pretty rare to reject a paper that you've solicited.
1) Bad stuff sneaks in everywhere if you get lucky with two reviewers and an editor asleep at the wheel. Even good journals. Not usually this bad, though.
2) This isn't a particularly good journal and isn't a cardiovascular journal, so they probably got two reviewers who are not knowledgeable about the field.
3) It might also have been an invited paper. These medoum-low journals often solicit reviews, and it's pretty rare to reject a paper that you've solicited.