Re:A Net Neutrality Case Study
by InclinedPlane on Sunday October 17, 2010 @04:24PM
(#1801323)
This seems unrelated to net neutrality. In this case the ISP isn't restricting or preferring any content on its network, rather a content provider is discriminating based on ISP.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If anything it seems like it'd have more to do with antitrust law. It may not actually fall afoul of it in this case, but it gets into gray-area territory when you're using retaliatory actions in one market to put pressure on contract negotiations in a different market. Looks especially bad because Fox doesn't normally have a policy of negotiating per-ISP contracts for Hulu content, but made an exception to specifically block Cablevision.
That's correct. Fred seems to be arguing for "Content Neutrality", which is to say that any publisher must make all their content available to anyone.
Re:A Net Neutrality Case Study
by fredwilson on Sunday October 17, 2010 @08:48PM
(#1801900)
no i am not
if i subscribe/pay for content, i don't want some ISP blocking it because they are in a spat with the content owner
Re:A Net Neutrality Case Study
by InclinedPlane on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:08AM
(#1802341)
Is that what's happening? It seems like in this case it's the content provider who's blocking access based on ISP. Would any net neutrality law protect against this? Should it?
This is extremely frustrating. I've seen this exact response on a number of tech sites. The people who are supposed to be the most informed proponents of net neutrality don't even understand the basic concept.
Re:A Net Neutrality Case Study
by fredwilson on Sunday October 17, 2010 @08:47PM
(#1801895)
i understand the basic concepts
i've read them hundreds of times
this is about discrimination
Net Neutrality about making ISPs and governments treat all communications over the net equally. This creates a democratic platform, a free market of bits.
This situation is a company refusing to provide content to certain customers. Fox (through Hulu) is not providing content to specific IP ranges that they provide freely elsewhere. It is discrimination by Fox, but it is a separate issue from Net Neutrality. This could still happen if Net Neutrality legislation was in place.