Re:Lessons on How to Treat People
by rdtsc on Sunday October 17, 2010 @02:35PM
(#1801029)
Well it depends on your basic view on altruism. What is the basic motivation for it?
Do you think people are inherently selfish and even when the do good things they do it with an expectation of some kind of a greater payback (even if it is an emotional high) or do they do it because they want to simply help another without an expectation of a any payback whatsoever.
I haven't figured it out one way or another yet. But the story can be interpreted by both sides. The selfish side turns this into some kind of a lottery -- "Be good to people, you never know when you'll meet a Donald Trump in disguise and he will reward your beyond measure" or from the pure altruism side -- "Look be nice to people, it is the right thing to do, a small gesture one your part might make a large impact on them"
Then of course, as you mentioned, there is the fairy tale angle. Few would be impressed by an article that read something like : "It was a cold rainy night, I picked up a woman waiting for a bus in the rain and took her home. I don't know who she was or even her name. The end." I think those things happen to people but they just don't make good blog stories. But "Donald Trump in rags" story is just fantastic for story telling purposes and gets lots of attention.
Do you think people are inherently selfish and even when the do good things they do it with an expectation of some kind of a greater payback (even if it is an emotional high) or do they do it because they want to simply help another without an expectation of a any payback whatsoever.
I haven't figured it out one way or another yet. But the story can be interpreted by both sides. The selfish side turns this into some kind of a lottery -- "Be good to people, you never know when you'll meet a Donald Trump in disguise and he will reward your beyond measure" or from the pure altruism side -- "Look be nice to people, it is the right thing to do, a small gesture one your part might make a large impact on them"
Then of course, as you mentioned, there is the fairy tale angle. Few would be impressed by an article that read something like : "It was a cold rainy night, I picked up a woman waiting for a bus in the rain and took her home. I don't know who she was or even her name. The end." I think those things happen to people but they just don't make good blog stories. But "Donald Trump in rags" story is just fantastic for story telling purposes and gets lots of attention.