News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Georgia, a legal battle over electronic vs. paper voting by travisoneill1 on Monday September 17, 2018 @01:33PM (#18008005)
> I don't think it's a problem that happens, though

But how do you know. That's the issue. If P is the probability of getting caught, and C is the number of people caught then N ~= C/P. With our current system it seems like P is close to 0 so even with C = 0 there could be a lot of successful attempts.

Rigging a polling place is not viable because it would require coordination between multiple people and leave a clear mathematical trail after. So I would say that, including detection after the fact, that P > 0.5 and that the fact that it hasn't been caught means that N = 0.

> But by introducing voter ID systems you are very likely to skew elections away from the people least likely to possess accepted ID, i.e. the lowest socio-economic groups.

This is pretty much separate from my point but I am also skeptical about this. If someone can get to the polling place, stand in a line, and do paperwork to vote, then why could they not do pretty much the same thing to get an ID?

Re:In Georgia, a legal battle over electronic vs. paper voting by richmarr on Monday September 17, 2018 @02:29PM (#18008591)
> Rigging a polling place is not viable because...

This argument is sounds great but doesn't match reality

https://i.redditmedia.com/NITi8srtcW0xIfOQXPZda6zJNrpb_jRbwg...

Edit: Link to the paper: http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/early/2012/09/20/1210722109...

Re:In Georgia, a legal battle over electronic vs. paper voting by beat on Monday September 17, 2018 @02:54PM (#18008869)
Ok, rigging a polling place in a well-designed system under rule of law is not viable.

Consider the Minnesota example. In MN, all physical ballot handling, whether marked or unmarked, sealed or unsealed, must be done in the presence of members of at least two different political parties. Since the only ways to rig an election at the polling place are to either add, remove, or substitute ballots, this makes such fraud extremely difficult to do, especially at scale.

Re:In Georgia, a legal battle over electronic vs. paper voting by beat on Monday September 17, 2018 @02:01PM (#18008276)
Apples and oranges. Polling costs nothing; ID costs money. Polling places are usually within walking distance of home (at least in urban areas); license bureaus are scattered and distant.

My polling place is two blocks from my house. I can walk there, vote, and be home in 20 minutes. Last time I had to renew my license, it was a three hour ordeal that cost me money and an afternoon of work, and the nearest station is miles from my house (in a dense city).

Re:In Georgia, a legal battle over electronic vs. paper voting by travisoneill1 on Monday September 17, 2018 @02:06PM (#18008326)
This is a good point. Would be fine with SSN as a unique identifier with no paperwork presented. Would be as easy to fake as current system, but would generate an obvious signal when there is a fake number or collision.