Re:Strangeness of HN members.
by stcredzero on Sunday October 17, 2010 @12:39PM
(#1800732)
they demand that discussion be evidence-based
I think this is the crux. So often, the stuff that's snidely said, as if it's so true it's a joke, is just false. "That's so true" should be added to "what you can't say" and "what you have to say" as places to look for common misconceptions.
(In particular, I'm thinking of Smalltalk/Lisp = slow. In terms of HLL, there were often implementations what were impressively fast for the time. This had absolutely no effect on the frequency of these jokes.)
This may also explain some of the seriousness you sense.
they are unwilling to discuss startup ideas unless an implementation has been made
I think this is the crux. So often, the stuff that's snidely said, as if it's so true it's a joke, is just false. "That's so true" should be added to "what you can't say" and "what you have to say" as places to look for common misconceptions.
http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html
(In particular, I'm thinking of Smalltalk/Lisp = slow. In terms of HLL, there were often implementations what were impressively fast for the time. This had absolutely no effect on the frequency of these jokes.)
This may also explain some of the seriousness you sense.
they are unwilling to discuss startup ideas unless an implementation has been made
Sounds evidence based to me.