News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by lostmsu on Sunday September 16, 2018 @12:51PM (#17999818)
When they were building their taxonomy, why did not they name its level, that includes both what they now call "dinosaur" and pterosaurs "dinosaur", and come up with a different name for their "dinosaur", if it is a common conception?
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by mannykannot on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:54AM (#18004989)
You seem to think the word was in use prior to the development of taxonomy, but the word "dinosaur" began as a specific taxonomic term, coined by Richard Owen. From the outset, it was recognized that not all Mesozoic reptiles were dinosaurs.

If conformance to common usage is an important taxonomic principle, then maybe taxonomists should put the label "fish" in their taxonomies so that whales and cuttlefish are included, as these were commonly regarded as a type of fish prior to the development of scientific taxonomy? This example shows why this principle does not work in general: "fish" would then include a great many species - including ourselves - that are not regarded as fish by anyone.

Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by tolmasky on Sunday September 16, 2018 @02:09PM (#18000189)
Well, for starters, as you can see from the graphic, you'd be getting a lot more than just "pterosaurs" if you did that, given that they are in fact quite distantly related, with several other layers of non-dinosaurs inbetween.
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by nitwit005 on Sunday September 16, 2018 @04:48PM (#18001018)
The goal of creating the taxonomy was presumably to create clear categories for research and scientific publications. I doubt they cared what an average person called a dinosaur, like the author of this article seems to, so the issue you're worrying about probably didn't seem important.
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by sulam on Sunday September 16, 2018 @01:07PM (#17999884)
It's almost as if the conception didn't come to be until _after_ the names for these things existed!
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by cobralibre on Sunday September 16, 2018 @02:06PM (#18000178)
I doubt that specialists are keen to adapt their terminology to reflect popular usage and would much prefer things to work the other way around. It looks like the word we should be using is 'avemetatarsalians'?
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by pbhjpbhj on Sunday September 16, 2018 @07:18PM (#18001821)
If one can't pedantically correct people then why even bother being an expert.
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by nonbel on Sunday September 16, 2018 @01:12PM (#17999904)
I think the "common conception" comes from Land Before Time and Jurassic Park, it seems almost everything we learned about dinosaurs from those movies is wrong.

Edit:

I just looked it up and discovered both were made by Steven Speilberg...

Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by monocasa on Sunday September 16, 2018 @01:34PM (#18000004)
Nah, pterodactyls and such were commonly taught to children to be dinosaurs before Jurassic Park and Land Before Time came out.

Source: was child before 1988.

Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by nonbel on Sunday September 16, 2018 @01:43PM (#18000043)
Where do you think it originated then?
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by chungy on Sunday September 16, 2018 @04:38PM (#18000961)
To be fair to Jurassic Park, I'm not sure its pterodactyls were explicitly claimed to be dinosaurs, and much of the film talked about non-dinosaur extinct species being resurrected as well (eg, ancient plant life).

Maybe it wasn't the filmmakers intent, but they have plausible deniability here. :)

Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by eftychis on Monday September 17, 2018 @03:42AM (#18003920)
Exactly. I am pretty certain, no such claim was made by the movie. And although it mixes a bunch or eras together, it does not claim to have just brought back dinosaurs.
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by jMyles on Sunday September 16, 2018 @03:35PM (#18000653)
Can you link to a source with some detail on what was wrong with those films? Particularly Jurassic Park?
Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by nonbel on Sunday September 16, 2018 @03:52PM (#18000734)
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2009/feb/08/jurassic-par...

Or search: "Jurassic park wrong about dinosaurs"

Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by jMyles on Sunday September 16, 2018 @05:26PM (#18001237)
This doesn't seem very strong to me.

OK, so I have been misinformed about velociraptor - I'll picture it smaller and with feathers. And brachiosaurus might not have been able to made a sound or stand on hind legs.

But I don't think that these relatively small details have left a generation woefully misinformed about dinosaurs.

If there are major things wrong with the film - if, for example, dinosaurs weren't as "bird-like" as the film made them seem (that seemed to me to be a major overture), then sure, I'd really like to read about that.

Re:Why a Pterosaur Is Not a Dinosaur by nonbel on Monday September 17, 2018 @01:32AM (#18003452)