News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by mathgenius on Sunday September 16, 2018 @07:57AM (#17998487)
> Yes, I know that quantum key distribution is a potential replacement for public-key cryptography. But come on -- does anyone expect a system that requires specialized communications hardware and cables to be useful for anything but niche applications?

I don't think there is any inherent reason why this would have to be done using "specialized communications hardware and cables". Didn't the Chinese just demonstrate entanglement sharing via satellite?

I could imagine a post-quantum computing era where it is even possible to know, with certainty, if you have been hacked, or data breached, because of quantum cryptography. We are not any where near this kind of technology right now, but the physics is real.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by ThePhysicist on Sunday September 16, 2018 @08:54AM (#17998687)
Yes, sounds a lot like the "I think there is a world market for maybe five computers" prediction by IBM's president in 1943.

Practical quantum cryptography is actually not that far away IMHO as the theory is solid and there have been many successful test deployments in the field already.

Sure the equipment is specialized but not much more than e.g. the electronics that you need for a mobile baseband station or other specialized applications. You mostly need a good single-photon source and some high-quality optical components and there's no fundamental obstacle to producing those in large quantities and (eventually) for an affordable price. Also, high-quality fiber-optical cables are expensive but not prohibitively so, hence intra-city quantum links seem absolutely feasible and even inter-city connections are doable (and as you pointed out even satellite or line-of-sight communication is possible).

In my understanding the main issue that most cryptographers have with schemes like quantum key distribution is that they require classical cryptography in the bootstrapping process, so by their argument they can never be better than those classical schemes. They often forget to mention though that the adversary needs to be able to crack the classical cryptography during the key exchange process (i.e. within a few milliseconds to seconds), so the method is still much safer than any classical key exchange method except if you're facing a god-like adversary.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by posterboy on Sunday September 16, 2018 @03:53PM (#18000743)
The "five computers" taken out of context might seem ridiculous but it is hard to believe that wouldnt have been obvious back then and so must have been understood differently, e.g. five mainframes to connect to per terminal and/or diversion to discourage competition. And it's not qualified over time, so it might have meant the very near future.

... or five architectures, five development boxes and the rest restricted implementations, ie. five different co-processors e.g. for time table scheduling which were selling by the time already.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by lokedhs on Sunday September 16, 2018 @11:56PM (#18003094)
The Wikipedia page on Watson discusses attempts at finding the source for this quote, but explains that there seems to be no consensus on this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_J._Watson

It does quote Howard Aiken saying this in 1952:

    Originally one thought that if there were a half dozen
    large computers in this country, hidden away in research 
    laboratories, this would take care of all requirements
    we had throughout the country
Even though it's likely that Watson never made this particular statement, the sentiment that the statement itself carries was a real one, and certainly existed in the 40's.

What would be interesting to know is when the shift happened from computers being seen as a niche tool to something that everybody would use.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by A2017U1 on Monday September 17, 2018 @01:00AM (#18003337)
> Sure the equipment is specialized but not much more than e.g. the electronics that you need for a mobile baseband station

Was under the impression that these computers were supercooled down to near absolute zero otherwise they are overwhelmed by decoherence, this problem has been solved?

Achieving those temperatures is a fairly involved process.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by ThePhysicist on Monday September 17, 2018 @08:16AM (#18005111)
For quantum cryptography you don't need qubits but entangled photons, and you need to be able to create pairs of these and measure the polarization of individual photons with high efficiency. Both of these things can be accomplished at room temperature (though there are technologies for photon detection that require cooling to very low temperatures).
Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by A2017U1 on Thursday September 20, 2018 @06:39AM (#18031187)
Intriguing, thanks for this.

Really enjoy the topic but find it hard to parse some claims that come out. D-wave a while ago made some bold statements that were shot down by many respected in the field, yet they seem to be progressing still and putting out papers.

Simply measuring power in qubits seems to be not the entire story yet most reporting on the subject often boils down to that. I should read up more.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by hannob on Sunday September 16, 2018 @11:40AM (#17999420)
> I could imagine a post-quantum computing era where it is even possible to know, with certainty, if you have been hacked, or data breached, because of quantum cryptography.

How so? (Because none of that seems to even remotely have anything to do with quantum cryptography. It's a key exchange - and one with some very bad properties I might say, because it assumes a hell of a lot of things already existing like an authenticated channel. But it does nothing to detect breaches or whether you've been hacked.)

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by nabla9 on Sunday September 16, 2018 @10:56AM (#17999220)
That amounts of specialized hardware. Strong lasers and receivers for each user, network of quantum repeater satellites. How do you connect to your bank in a cloudy day or when it rains?
Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by abdullahkhalids on Sunday September 16, 2018 @12:48PM (#17999800)
Quantum key distribution is a method of securely exchanging a symmetric key from afar. Once you have that symmetric key, you encode your message with the key (say using a one-time pad), and send it via a classical channel as usual, and the other person decodes it.

So what could happen is that that every month you could have a session with your bank to exchange a 100MB secure key using quantum key distribution. Then during the month, you and the bank could use regular internet to communicate securely using the key.

Re:Quantum Computing and Cryptography by smarky0x7CD on Monday September 17, 2018 @10:26AM (#18006198)
Fiber optic ines also work alright.