If they had done only third-party auth I bet the top comment would be complaining that there's no site-specific credentials
Yes, and that's why you need both...
maintaining systematic password diversity is a high-cognitive task which imposes a barrier of entry to your app that's simply not worth it for me
You should really give 1Password a try.
Please please do not make me create another username/password combination; maintaining systematic password diversity is a high-cognitive task which imposes a barrier of entry to your app that's simply not worth it for me.
(I'm actually very agnostic of what drop-ins you use -openid, google auth, hell even facebook auth -just as long as it's something I can just click through (granted I'm logged in to those sites))