Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by jacquesm on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:45AM
(#17969931)
I can't get enough of that project, it's brilliant in picking the one target that is still feasible and yet so complex that it illustrates the magic that makes an integrated circuit useful: the only reason you are using a CPU is because it is integrated. A non-integrated CPU would be prohibitively expensive and terribly slow, even with today's surface mounted devices.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by leoc on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @02:58PM
(#17971926)
Modern CPUs, sure. Apparently the original microprocessors were actually faster when implemented with discrete components though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datapoint_2200
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by hathawsh on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @03:17PM
(#17972133)
Wow, as that Wikipedia article explains, the 8008 was effectively developed through a prototyping process involving 100 TTL chips. Also, it sounds like CTC (Computer Terminal Corporation) invented the circuit and later gave Intel full rights to turn it into a chip and improve upon it. Intel was simply a contractor who knew when to do some work for free in exchange for IP rights. Did Intel have any idea how successful their strategy would turn out? Amazing!
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by zerohp on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:19PM
(#17973468)
Prototyping using TTL chips to validate the logic design was still common throughout the 1970s. 100 TTL chips is pretty small.
The Motorola 68000 team published several papers that are still available through IEEE that describe the design process. They built a prototype from TTL chips which allowed them to rapidly iterate the microcode, nanocode, and programmed logic arrays without having to wait for samples to come back from manufacturing.
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by ChickeNES on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:13PM
(#17975676)
I'd love to read them, could you share a doi or link?
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by jacquesm on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:21PM
(#17973490)
That must have been several boards at least, even at TTL scale integration and using components like adders and decoders as the building blocks.
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by jandrese on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:26PM
(#17974475)
There is a FAQ on the page that explains that a 68k built in the same way would require a board 1.7m square.
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by jacquesm on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:53PM
(#17974673)
Which is not practical for board size, so it most likely would have been some kind of backplane with plug-in boards for the various main sections of the CPU.
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by utopcell on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:47PM
(#17974954)
..or much smaller in a 3D setup.
Re:The MOnSter 6502: transistor-scale replica of classic MOS...
by mycall on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:54PM
(#17975874)
I wish they had a variable speed, even down to manual clock cycles. Once they add the new LEDs on the next revision, it would be a wonderful learning tool to watch the state changes.