News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by rerx on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:41AM (#17968604)
The picture is taken from this study: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.3810/psm.2011.09.1933 (use Sci-Hub if you do not belong to an institution paying for access)
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by wjnc on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:02AM (#17968851)
The fallacy in this article is as follows:

(quote) "A cross-section of 40 high-level recreational athletes (“masters athletes”) who were aged 40 to 81 years and trained 4 to 5 times per week underwent tests of health/activity, body composition, quadriceps peak torque (PT), and magnetic resonance imaging of bilateral quadriceps."

The 81 yr old that trains 4-5x (!) a week is a lot more special than the 40 yr old (that's my hypothesis at least). Thus any regression is spurious, since we are sampling from different quantiles! So you don't know anything about the correlation with age.

I'm not disputing that training 4-5x a week keeps muscles strong and the body lean, but it's hardly prescriptive. It's like winning the lottery will make you richer when you retire.

I've tried to reach the authors about this when the article came out, but alas. A letter to the editor in a to me unknown journal seemed not the best use of my time. I've even got code demonstrating the fallacy with quantile regression ;)

Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by citation_please on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:11AM (#17968945)
Huh. Well let's assume causality points in only one direction, genetics->tissue->ability, then I'm screwed and there's nothing I can do about it. Let's assume that it at least points partially in the other direction, ability->tissue, now I can keep my tissue healthy by exercising.

Since I don't know for sure which direction causality points, I'm going to take the path of maximal self-determinism and try to stay fit as long as possible.

Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by maxerickson on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:10AM (#17968933)
The paper's discussion contains this statement:

In addition, studying masters athletes partially limits the applicability of these data to the general population of aging adults who do not aggressively exercise 4 to 5 times per week.

It's unfortunate that such a statement won't make it into popular treatments, but the paper doesn't get very far out over its skis.

Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by wjnc on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:35AM (#17969815)
My point is they are not sampling from genpop And they are sampling Different populations with age rising. I've met quite a few fit 60 yr olds, but have never seen a that fit 80 yr old.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by toasterlovin on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:12AM (#17968955)
Your criticism is spot on. Separately, though, there is a growing community of people using weight training on older folks. It seems incredibly effective. Check out The Barbell Prescription by the Starting Strength folks if you’re interested.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by henryw on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:00AM (#17969448)
Training 4-5x a week is within your control. Winning the lottery is not.

I get up every weekday morning at 5 to 6am to do a spin or group fitness class and lift 1 to 2 times per week Arnold superset style. I'm loving this lifestyle. (I guess the gym being Equinox helps.)

Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by jmull on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:32AM (#17969772)
> Training 4-5x a week is within your control.

That may not be true for a large proportion of people in their 80s.

Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by YinglingLight on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:46AM (#17969949)
Those in their 80s have nothing but free time. Of course they won't have the energy to train 4-5x a week if they have been sedentary the last half of their life.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by henryw on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:02PM (#17970135)
Maybe they can start with 1-2x and then work their way up to 4-5x after awhile.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by wjnc on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:38AM (#17969856)
I agree with jmull here. In my personal opinion things like intermittent fasting might be a lot more broadly applicable to the elderly than exercising 4x a week or becoming a triathlete.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by cdubzzz on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:56AM (#17970071)
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age by lotsofpulp on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:43AM (#17968628)
Thank you! I couldn't come up with a reputable source on reverse image search to figure out if it's fake or not.