Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed?
by enriquto on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:41AM
(#17967464)
> Would you argue that they'd need to air that dirty laundry in public?
Yes, airing the problem as publicly as possible would be the right thing to do, out of respect for the readers of the journal.
Removing the paper from the publication record is acceptable, as long as it is done very openly, as a kind of "erratum".
Would you argue that Social Text would, in that situation, still have some sort of duty to publish the paper? Would you argue they'd have a responsibility to give it a prominent, permanent, place in their archives to avoid accusations of having "disappeared" it? Would you argue that they'd need to air that dirty laundry in public? If they did air it all publicly and honestly, would you treat that as a form of bullying of Sokal and his accomplice(s)? Remember: that would be the powerful journal leveling accusations of deliberate fraud against an academic who submitted the paper, and accusations of, at the very least, dishonesty and violation of review processes against one of their own.