News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by maxawaytoolong on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:00PM (#1796023)
"... and own a monopoly"

Like Bill Gates and Microsoft, who were actually convicted as monopolists?

After working in aid in Africa, I have to say I agree more with the Mexican monopolist than the American one.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jakarta on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:44PM (#1796198)
That's the point. Bill Gates was convicted of being a monopolist and checks were put on what his company could and could not do. That does not happen in Mexico.

In more extreme cases, look at John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil. Rockefeller used to be the wealthiest person in the world (according to some, if you inflation adjust his money, he may have been the wealthiest person in the last 200 years). His company was broken into parts in order to promote competition. Same goes for the Bell Telecom companies in America, they were also all broken up. We have checks in place to curb the anti-competitive forces of certain companies.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lionhearted on Friday October 15, 2010 @10:04PM (#1797106)
> In more extreme cases, look at John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil. Rockefeller used to be the wealthiest person in the world ... We have checks in place to curb the anti-competitive forces of certain companies.

If anyone is curious about John Rockefeller, I'd very strongly recommend "Titan" by Ron Chernow, which is a very detailed and fair biography of Rockefeller. It's one of the more important biographies I've read for my own development as a person.

After reading it, I'm thoroughly convinced that the oil industry would've been much smaller and much more expensive without Rockefeller's work, and he was a genius about chemistry, engineering, distribution, and all sorts of things. Rockefeller is probably in the 10 Americans of wealth created of all time - oil prices fell a huge amount due to Rockefeller's leadership, ability to find talent. He paid people well and treated them well. Did a lot of philanthropy, and raised his kids really modestly too. They lived in a three bedroom home with his wife and six kids for a long time, treated people really well. His kids didn't know they were one of the wealthiest families in America until they were teenagers.

Really an amazing guy. I'd recommend that biography to anyone. I think most people, even people who strongly believe in social causes and regulation, will admire the guy a lot after reading his biography. He did a massively lot of good for the world.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:25PM (#1798340)
I haven't read Titan, but I can recommend "The Myth of the Robber Barrons". Excellent book.

The short story is this: All those robber barrons did far more good for society than the government that broke them up. The propaganda about how they were doing so much harm and needed to be broken up for the good of society is the basic propaganda of socialism. But of course, since it is taught as history, people believe it.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by volski on Friday October 15, 2010 @06:52PM (#1796654)
In more extreme cases, look at John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil. Rockefeller used to be the wealthiest person in the world (according to some, if you inflation adjust his money, he may have been the wealthiest person in the last 200 years). His company was broken into parts in order to promote competition.

John D. Rockefeller actually ended up being a lot richer because the courts broke up Standard Oil[1]. He went from having a controlling stake in the most powerful company in oil, to having a controlling stake in most of the powerful companies in the whole oil industry (ExxonMobil, Chevron, BP, Shell). I just wanted to clarify that point because the order in which your statement was crafted kind of made it seem like the courts broke up his wealth when they actually expanded it.

1.Rockefeller, who had rarely sold shares, held over 25% of Standard’s stock at the time of the breakup. He, as well as all stockholders, received proportionate shares in each of the 34 companies...The companies’ combined net worth rose fivefold and Rockefeller’s personal wealth jumped to $900,000,000.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_D._Rockefeller

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by napierzaza on Friday October 15, 2010 @08:54PM (#1796949)
I agree with your statement, while at the same time it was the monopoly that got him to the position he was in. It's hard not to make money once you're at that point. I don't think he could have gotten that rich if actual competition existed and he was investing in hundreds of companies. He didn't do any manoeuvring to get his stakes in all those separate companies, unless you count back room deals.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:30PM (#1798356)
A monopoly is someone who owns an entire market. In the history of america, the only monopolies that have existed were government granted ones, like the US Postal Service. The government passed a law prohibiting the offering of first class mail. At the time they did this, there was a thriving and growing and diverse mail delivery system made up of thousands of small businesses and private contractors.

Standard Oil was never a monopoly, and never had monopoly pricing power. Standard oil was only ever able to get large because they quickly and constantly drove down the price of gasoline.

There is this tendency for americans to call businesses that are not monopolies under the definition to be monopolies to justify using violence against them (it is violence when a company is forcibly broken up or forced to not engage in "anti-competitive" (by which they really mean "competitive") activities.)

The reality is, none of these businesses were monopolies, and as much as I hate microsoft, they weren't a monopoly. Existing laws would have been sufficient for enforcement against microsoft for their crimes, which included fraud and misrepresentation. But the "anti-trust" laws are all about preserving government power and are used only against businesses that become big enough to wield influence and thus attract opponents in government... usually opponents in government in the pocket of competing businesses.

The US would be a better country and have a more robust economy, if Standard Oil had never been broken up. This and the "anti-trust" movement is a triumph of socialism over capitalism.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jakarta on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:20PM (#1798641)
You do a great job at ignoring the facts.

Standard Oil was able to use anti-competitive forces against competitors. They specifically were able to extract better rates for the transportation of oil with the railroad companies which helped give them a more competitive cost structure than peers. Because of the high cost of capital required at the time, many peers were driven out of business and were forced to sell to Rockefeller.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Sunday October 17, 2010 @04:46AM (#1799949)
I love how ideological nonsense that bears no releationship to historical facts is considered "facts" and by not goose stepping along with your fascist ideology you feel justified in calling me ignorant. When its painfully obvious that all you are able to contribute to the conversation is a poor repetition of your vague memories of the propaganda you were told about the situation, when in reality, vertical integration, including the purchasing of transportation systems gave standard oil a competitive advantage. This is known as competition, and is not "anti-competitive". In fact, if you use the phrase "anti-competitive" seriously, you should lose the right to post on this website because you reveal yourself to be an unthinking socialist, and if you ever managed to start a company, you would surely fuck it up by following your ideology over reality.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by cromulent on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:56PM (#1798725)
Wikipedia has a pretty good definition:

In economics, a monopoly exists when a specific individual or an enterprise has sufficient control over a particular product or service to determine significantly the terms on which other individuals shall have access to it.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Sunday October 17, 2010 @04:53AM (#1799957)
This is not a definition, this is an expression of the leftist ideological position. I have seen many situations on Wikipedia where factually correct edits are reversed because they disagree with the ideology of the wikipedia editors who have stature.

It is kinda like hacker news where a useful comment like mine is voted down to zero, while someone calling me names and repeating ignorant comments that are consistent with the groupthink of the left, get modded up.

It is not that their name calling and ideological regurgitation are superior to my argument... it is that people vote based on ideology, often when they are profoundly ignorant of the reality.

I suggest that you not use Wikipedia as a source for definitions, as that one is particularly heinous. In common usage one could use the term "monopoly" to describe entities with strong pricing power, but common usage is not usage in economics, yet the wikipedia definition starts "in economics".

Any "Economist" who defines a monopoly as a company that does not have ownership of the entire market, is an ideologue pretending to be an economist.

In economics, they use this term correctly.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by cromulent on Sunday October 17, 2010 @11:45AM (#1800570)
According to my economics textbooks, when you say "ownership of the entire market" you are talking about a pure monopoly, which is different to a monopoly. You don't need the entire market to have monopolistic power.

So, I would disagree with your definitions, and your assertion that "in economics, they use this term correctly".

I would also suggest that your assertions seem somewhat ideological. Many people agree that trusts are bad for capitalism in that they restrict competition, and are not evidence of socialism.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:46PM (#1813007)
I love how you just made up a term and then claimed that using the word wrong is justified because you made up a different term for the correct definiton.

Of course, you've never opened an economic texbook in your life.

I also love how you claim that my references to history are ideological assertions, then you make a broad and profoundly ignorant ideological assertion as a counter argument, except that, of course, you don't make an actual argument, you just say "many people believe".

Many people believe there is a good, that's not proof that its true.

You are a fucking ignorant socialist, and it is consequently no wonder that you are so dishonest as well.

It is fucktards like you that make hacker news (and any "social" news site) not worth participating on,..... because there are just too many ignorant, low intelligence people downvoting those who bothered to learn something and who bother to think.

Just in case there's any question of our relative positions here.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by cromulent on Friday October 22, 2010 @05:48PM (#1821650)
I'm afraid you are too kind in attributing the definition of "pure monopoly" to me.

http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=...

I'm sorry that you got downvoted. Take it easy.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by Tycho on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:37PM (#1798522)
What di you make of the DeBeers 10 year diamond monopoly? If all the supposed monopolies out there, this seems the hardest to debunk. I read one economist say they were really a cartel with government protection, but he didn't cite any evidence. DeBeers seem to have controlled the trade through their own shrewdness. Only point I can think against it is there's nothing to stop people reselling diamond rings so it's wrong to say they control the market.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Sunday October 17, 2010 @04:49AM (#1799950)
The only way a cartel can work is via government enforcement. Cartels can try to fix prices, but as soon as they do, if the price is above the free-market price, members of the cartel will try to gain marketshare by selling under the table at a lower price. Cartels are not sustainable in a free market for this reason.

I can't comment on DeBeers because I do not know enough of the history of the situation. I will say, though, that diamonds are essentially worthless, and it is primarily by brilliant propaganda / advertising that people continue to buy them.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by smokeyj on Saturday October 16, 2010 @09:27AM (#1797921)
True monopolies are often the side effect of regulation, telecom not being an exception. Big companies lobby for regulation to create a steeper barrier to entry for start-ups, effectively mitigating competition.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by sprout on Friday October 15, 2010 @05:30PM (#1796366)
Wow, that's a load of non-sequiturs. Monopoly is a side effect of the massive corruption plaguing Mexico. Microsoft doesn't even come close.

As for aid in Africa, that's a specific charity you worked with in Africa. There are people who do good work there. Dismissing aid because people are bad at it is like dismissing software development because people are bad at it. One way or another it's necessary.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by yters on Friday October 15, 2010 @09:42PM (#1797048)
I went to a missionary conference once where an African princess came in and talked to us. Exactly the place where you'd expect a plea for more aid, right?

Well, not really. She said we needed to mind our own business and let Africa take care of itself.

Then a Bono video from his opulent mansion came on with some sort of campaign to end world poverty or something.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by euccastro on Saturday October 16, 2010 @03:57AM (#1797581)
"Minding your own business" may be a loaded phrase there, though. Much of the misery in Africa is a direct result of western exploitation. That includes much misery the proximate cause of which is corrupt leaders. Guess who keeps many of them there.

She has a point that truly letting Africa "take care of itself" may be more effective than any aid. But that statement is not primarily about aid, and withdrawing aid doesn't help with the subjacent problems.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by huherto on Saturday October 16, 2010 @11:19AM (#1798079)
"Monopoly is a side effect of the massive corruption plaguing Mexico" Hold it. Please don`t make broad accusations. If you have any specific information about Telmex say so, but do not generalize. That badly hurts our reputation and it has been said many times that people just take it as true. Mexico has corruption levels that are consistent with outher countries with similar development levels. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:33PM (#1798364)
Americans operate under the delusion that our government is not corrupt. They see corrupt actions as legitimate. For instance, governments here regularly steal property from private citizens without having the citizens be charged with a crime (let alone convicted.)
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by bilbo0s on Friday October 15, 2010 @07:25PM (#1796766)
Just to round it out...

There is also the logical fallacy known as "Appeal to Authority" in @maxawaytoolong's comment.

But we should not be logic nazis I suppose.

My own opinion is that both Slim and Gates can be right at the same time. Lots of businesses provide for lots of people...but not all.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by damoncali on Saturday October 16, 2010 @02:33PM (#1798508)
Where is being a monopolist a crime?
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jshen on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:12PM (#1796070)
except one could say that mexico represents Slim's philosophy and America (and most industrialized countries) more closely represent Buffet's/Gate's philosophies.

I think it's clear which philosophy has the better outcome for people in general.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by makmanalp on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:19PM (#1796098)
Wow, and this one is a false analogy. Just because one is from America and the other is from Mexico doesn't mean that they've been the sole affectors of their respective countries' welfares, or that the current (good or bad) state of their countries is a direct result of their actions.

What is this, fallacy friday?

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by bilbo0s on Friday October 15, 2010 @07:28PM (#1796774)
I was thinking it was fallacy friday too.

I think when people debate things like Charity, they take leave of logic.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:37PM (#1798369)
I think the leave of logic is to reject economics and just believe in something for ideological reasons.

Slim is making an economic point. Part of the reason there is no end of poverty in this US is due to the "War on Poverty" which destroyed the charity system (via government takeover of welfare programs) and has inhibited job creation (via government regulation, taxation and inflation.)

We were well on our way to ending poverty in this country before the New Deal was done to us.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jshen on Friday October 15, 2010 @11:40PM (#1797274)
Mexico has virtually no safety net, a fraction of redistribution of wealth for social good such as infrastructure and education, etc

Using taxes for laying a foundation that provides greater opportunity for society in general is very similar to doing it with charity. Not doing it is very similar to saying, "leave it to the private sector"

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Saturday October 16, 2010 @01:38PM (#1798374)
It is "very similar" in the way that buying a meal at mcdonalds is "very similar" to being mugged. In one case you do it voluntarily and the people involved are incentivized to do it efficiently.... and in the other case you do it at gun point and the person involved has no incentive to spend the money efficiently.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jshen on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:38AM (#1802404)
i disagree with the premise that the only motivation people have is personal greed.

I disagree with the depiction of taxation is a mugging, even libertarians want government when push comes to shove. Afghanistan is what it's like with no real government, and no one is for that. Even libertarians want the government to put a gun to your head to enforce contract law!

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by lzw on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:41PM (#1812987)
I never said the only motivation people have is personal greed.

Taxation is literally a mugging. And you are in error to assume that governments cannot exist without mugging. Businesses provide services and charge for them. A government could do this as well.

don't speak for libertarians if you aren't one. If you are one, you've failed to apply the zero aggression principle.

You also seem to fail to distinguish between using violence defensively against an agressor, which is moral, and using violence offensively to steal from someone (eg: taxation) which is immoral.

Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jshen on Saturday October 23, 2010 @01:43PM (#1823950)
So you believe there should be no government? We have many examples of this throughout modern history. They were all shit holes. Every country on this planet that is a decent place to live has a strong central government. QED
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by maxawaytoolong on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:20PM (#1796100)
one could say that, but I don't think anyone would would actually say that with a straight face.
Re:World's Richest Man: 'Charity Doesn't Solve Anything' by jshen on Friday October 15, 2010 @11:40PM (#1797276)
Read my reply to the above commenter