Do you believe that the CEO of any company that fails should be jailed or just banks?
There was undoubtedly plenty of hubris, greed and incompetence to go round. I also believe that some of what occurred should, in hindsight, have been illegal. But having some sort of sacrifice to appease the gods is a little outdated.
Oh, and yes, all the CEOs were replaceable. Irreplaceability is a very silly argument.
That is the main issue. Nothing you can do against individuals that acted legally.
However hindsight happened very quickly, almost from day 1. There is no excuse that the bailouts didn't come with extremely punitive string attached only loosened after the law had been updated.
That did not happen. There is no moral to the story, no happy ending. Worse, hindsight works both ways. Maybe the current generation of financial company executives have learned their lesson, but the next one will have no such reserve.
We can punish them for actions deemed wrong even if legal. We do it to the poorest of criminals all the time, through creative legal maneuvers that judges have decided don't violate ex post facto. It is telling that we never do this for white collar crime.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_rating_agencies_and_the...
At a minimum they should have lost all their money and not walk away with hundreds of millions of dollars.
Sorry, but it's simply not that simple.
So prevention is the name of the game. But that requires competent regulators and oversight. Compliance and reporting laws, and so on. Investigators with staff and time, prosecutors willing to chase a case, and of course independent judges.
The SEC and DoJ could have tried to bring more charges, and they got billions in deferred prosecution agreements, maybe not enough though. (They - I mean DPAs - are not shiny like a jail time verdict, but they do work pretty well https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/soci-t-g-n-rale-sa-agrees-pay... see also https://scholarship.law.unc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?httpsred... )
If we want to make up for the money lost by the innocent, then we can chose to tax those we think benefited. But that's completely different than blind vengeance.
Watch Silicon Valley scramble to adjust their moral compass if Tesla fails in the same manner.
What couldn't happen legally?
Problem is though, even if laws were passed, once 2008 fades far enough into the past you'll get someone with a really bright idea, "Hey there's too much regulation stifling our economy. If we just got rid of all those pesky laws the free market would create a utopia!" Because every tom, dick and harry wants their chance to repeat history after the last tom, dick and harry have died.
We have the laws. What we lack if the will and the power to apply them.
Economist had calculated a significant number of deaths (worldwide) resulted from the 2007 / 2008 crisis. I believe the number was approx 30,000 (but it may be higher).
Editorial: If we don't have laws for such things then the elected should be shackled for their neglect and failure.
Legislative neglect also isn’t a crime that lawmakers can be prosecuted under. You can, however, not vote for them during their reelection campaign. You can also vote for lawmakers that would bother to push for such laws.
For better or worse, western countries are generally strong rule of law ones. If this was a country like China that practiced rule by law instead, I’m sure they could find something to throw them in jail on, but it isn’t.
What does “effort” mean here? Even an investigation requires some kind of suspicion of foul play. They can’t just investigate someone because they are out to get them (well, at least they shouldn’t).
It's unclear whether you know what "precedent" means in a legal context.
You could have prosecuted and imprisoned all of MERS's officers for racketeering.
The first happened in teensy numbers, the second, not at all.
(copyedited)
Being greedy is not a crime. Taking advantage of lax regulations is not a crime. Being bailed out with tax dollars for risks that paid you off privately if they won is not a crime.
Maybe that's your point, but therein lies the problem. Doing all these things has an upside but no downside, therefore we're encouraging antisocial behaviour.
However, plenty of others aren't interested in that. What they seek is simply what we are told the republic promises us and the rest of the world.
That is, justice.
Instead, per the article, there was no justice and no closure. __And__ the voice(s) of the mob(s) - in the absence of justice - are raising louder and louder. The impact from 2008 is far from over.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_rating_agencies_and_the...
But there are many behaviors which aren't "crimes" but which are morally repulsive.
The danger of not reacting, one way or another, to such inequities is that people lose faith in the system. Already, the election of Trump and rise of fascist sentiments everywhere are like a giant "fuck you" to politics as usual.
It can get much worse. At some point, as one billionaire said, "the pitchforks are coming". I don't think we'll be able to avoid it the way things are going.
> But there are many behaviors which aren't "crimes" but which are morally repulsive.
I don't agree with that concept. I don't think it's possible to legislate morality and the entire concept is downright scary. What's even more scary though is metering out justice based on perceived morality. Justice needs to be impartial, otherwise you're literally putting people in jail because your dislike them.
> The danger of not reacting, one way or another, to such inequities is that people lose faith in the system. Already, the election of Trump and rise of fascist sentiments everywhere are like a giant "fuck you" to politics as usual.
On the contrary, I see the election of Trump as a demonstration of people's faith in the system. It worked as intended and they got what they (electorally speaking) asked for.
> It can get much worse. At some point, as one billionaire said, "the pitchforks are coming". I don't think we'll be able to avoid it the way things are going.
I really doubt that. I've got significantly more faith in our shared humanity and the rule of law. I do find it disturbing how a lot of the politics on the left has shifted from policy disagreement to directly stoking violence. But it'll eventually pass.
Unemployment and immigration policy is at a tipping point where the only choice for employers is going to be rising wages. The left is going to have a hard time arguing that's a bad thing.
Why would the left argue that rising wages is a bad thing anyway? It seems that a significant subset of the left has been beating the “we need higher minimum wages and more wage growth overall" drum for a while.
Is it just because they strictly prefer a governmental rather than a natural market solution? Or something else?
> I don't agree with that concept. I don't think it's possible to legislate morality...
We don't have to "legislate" the morality but we do have a responsibility for doing _something_. "Rule of law" means nothing if one class of people has subverted the law, enforcement and governance to their benefit at the expense of everyone else.If the government, or specifically the justice system, is going to be involved in that "_something_" then we need laws that can be enforced by prosecutors and interpreted by judges. If you want that to include actions that is currently legal but which you find morally reprehensible (ex: the actions of these finance executives) then that needs to be codified in law before you can go after them. And that's literally legislating morality.
> "Rule of law" means nothing if one class of people has subverted the law, enforcement and governance to their benefit at the expense of everyone else.
They haven't subverted anything. They've taken advantage of a system that is available to them. Ditto for veterans who get subsidized school or home loans, Tesla drivers who get $7,500 in EV credits, small business owners who get SBA loans, or anyone else that takes a dime from the pool of money we call public spending. You could argue that anyone of those programs is to the benefit of only the receiver and the detriment of the rest of us[1].
And there's already a system in place to change it. Elect politicians that will make the changes you want and understand the positions of the ones that are currently in power.
With all the demonizing of wall street in regards to the 2008 crisis, most fail to go back to the true cause of the crisis, i.e. the repeal of the Glass-Stegall Act[2] via the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act[3] signed by President Clinton in 1999. It took almost a decade but the entire "too big to fail" concept grew from that repeal.
[1]: I generally don't like qualifying my statements but for clarity, I'm saying you could argue it. I'm not saying that I would necessarily argue against those (well except the EV one which is asinine...).
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_steagall
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bl...
As pointed out elsewhere, the repeal of Glass-Stegall was not the problem. Not only do most other countries not even have an equivalent law, but the crisis was triggered when a standalone investment bank failed.
Interestingly it was also involved in the solution as it allowed some of the mergers that softened the collapse.
What are laws if they are not an attempt to codify and enforce a group morality?
Editorial: In the context of such history, DJT is the least of my worries.
6 of those 8 years fighting a conservative Congress in both houses. Only 4 months of those other 2 years did he have enough Senate votes to bypass conservative filibusters. He spent that time/capital/effort squeezing ACA through.
The bottomline, zero effort was put into it. None. Given the magnitude that's not acceptable. I'm pretty sure DJT sent BHO a thank you card.
I would wonder what you'd say about a general who didn't know that using chemical warfare is a possible tribunal scenario.
We have a similar legal case in maritime law, where captains can be sued for anything that happens on their ships. If you can't take on that role and it's liability - then you shouldn't be the captain.
I don't think you read the article because it is based on a 700 page book about how it was revolutionary tech. It was just revolutionary finance tech. There was no ABCP before, there were no CDOs before, there were no central bank swaps before, there was no wholesale funding market, there were no offshore dollar banking market, etc.
It is hard to take seriously any arguments that the bankers were incompetent when you look at the sheer number of affected institutions -- you're left defending a claim that virtually every banker and most companies (look at the impacts on, say, Russian resource companies when they could no longer roll their dollar debt in wholesale funding markets in 2008) are incompetent. And that's always going to be difficult argument to make.
I don't need to defend that claim: most companies didn't care and neither they had enough resources to do their own, full due diligence into the state of America at the point of time. That's the job of the banks.
The fact that Russian companies held their debt in dollars has nothing to do with CDOs but rather their (false) belief in the stability of American economy.
What it seems like from the outside is they screwed the world over and completely got away with it on our dime.
I don't know if my impression is right or what would convince me the fact that there seemed to be no repercussions for their actions is somehow the right thing. Just saying that's how it seems.
I don't believe for a second those people were irreplaceable as some have suggested. People are replaced at giant companies all the time and the companies keep on functioning. If we need one example Steve Jobs death certainly shows that. Could pick any other CEO that left or was shoved out or past away.