Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed?
by kaitai on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:02AM
(#17959318)
But schooling in the US is biased in all sorts of ways, and trying to draw conclusions from that is being encouraged in this discussion.
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed?
by hackinthebochs on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @04:46PM
(#17963212)
True, but not all bias is created equal. You have to consider the nature of the potential bias and how it might affect measured outcomes. It's much less clear how bias might unnaturally increase variance than reduce it or alter the mean. But my point was mainly to argue against the conclusion that a lack of observed variance differences in some countries demonstrated the hypothesis false. I agree that the observed variance differences in western countries doesn't prove it true either.
If we're trying to draw conclusions about innate differences operationalized as distribution test scores, any kind of biased schooling undermines the ability to draw conclusions from that population.