News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tptacek on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:31AM (#17952061)
I think I agree with you about the Intelligencer, at least to the extent that I don't think it matters what the Intelligencer does.

But I disagree with you that a real journal has a duty to maintain a bad-faith off-topic out-of-process submission. That's a disservice to the cite record.

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by yorwba on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:55PM (#17953158)
Not following process is a disservice to the cite record, correct. Citations rely heavily on the assumption that you can refer you reader to a range of pages in a journal and they will be able to unambiguously determine the paper you are referring to.

So completely removing a paper that was published in violation of process is a process violation itself, undermining the reliability of citations. At least they replaced it by a paper of the same length, hopefully preventing any following papers from moving around, but they really shouldn't reuse space like that. Especially considering it's an online journal where pages are essentially free.