News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Larry Summers Calls Fed Bank Stress Test Results ‘Absurd’ by Symmetry on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:52AM (#17951773)
Buying up government bonds and thus forcing people to invest their money somewhere else had the effect of propping up asset prices but increasing the amount of money in circulation was more the intent of QE. The effect on asset prices was welcome but not really the main point. There's a lot less money than their is investment capital so every dollar printed had a correspondingly larger effect via the unit account role than via the store of value role. Increasing a pool of money from $1 trillion to $2 trillion should have a larger effect than increasing another from $50 trillion to $51 trillion.

And if QE were the whole of the story behind low interest rate I would really expect much higher inflation than what we're seeing.

Re:Larry Summers Calls Fed Bank Stress Test Results ‘Absurd’ by roymurdock on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:31AM (#17952507)

  M1 = cash/cash equivalents
  M2 = M1 + short term deposits
  M3 = M2 + long term deposits
M1 + M2 directly influence inflation - this is the money in circulation, greasing the wheels of the economy.

QE increased the monetary base by creating creating bank reserves (M3 long term deposits), re-capitalizing banks and companies after the financial crisis triggered collection chains many , giving them a clean sheet to borrow/loan again and make good on prior obligations (the ones that hadn't exploded).

In order for QE to affect inflation, banks would have to loan out these reserves, converting M3 money into M1/M2 - currency in circulation.

Banks only loaned out a fraction of the $4T they were given by the Fed.

The whole story is a global lack of demand in developed countries for loans/capital to help businesses invest.

Many companies aren't buying new machines (what would they buy?), and they aren't hiring new skilled workers (what skills do they need with no new machines?) - large contributing factor to wage stagnation.

Instead they are cutting costs - outsourcing departments, renting server time, looking to ML/AI to reduce reliance on costly humans with stagnating skill sets.

Interest rates are the cost of borrowing money. Interest rates are low because the demand for money and investment capital is low. There's a large supply of money and a decreasing amount of safe, productive places to invest it.

Re:Larry Summers Calls Fed Bank Stress Test Results ‘Absurd’ by Symmetry on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:39PM (#17953015)
My understanding is that one big reason that a lot of QE money didn't get loaned out was that the Fed suddenly started paying the banks on the excess reserves they were holding.
Re:Larry Summers Calls Fed Bank Stress Test Results ‘Absurd’ by roymurdock on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:39PM (#17953510)
Contributing factor but not the root cause.

Banks get paid 0.25% on excess reserves. If they can find better returns elsewhere than 0.25%, they'll try to convert those reserves into loans. 0.25% is better than nothing but still pretty awful ROI wise.

The Fed started paying interest on reserves "to establish a lower bound of the federal funds rate (FFR)" - it's another way to limit downside and ensure what rate banks are lending reserves to each other (instead of having that rate be 0% because none of the banks actually want/need more reserves). The FFR is useless to the Fed as a tool when it reaches 0 "zero lower bound" and there is no demand for the inter-bank exchange of reserves.

https://www.frbsf.org/education/publications/doctor-econ/201...

Re:Larry Summers Calls Fed Bank Stress Test Results ‘Absurd’ by Symmetry on Monday September 10, 2018 @03:30PM (#17954424)
Yeah, this was much more of an issue when excess reserves were getting 1% at the height of the crisis.