And all the other comments regarding other journals and their consistency of quality is where, exactly? I'm also missing any discussion of standards to judge quality articles and their application (or lack thereof)
I must be missing it because to me it looks like a bunch of usual political crap.
Assuming charitable intent, I understand that you might want to talk about honing one's ability to "read and evaluate journal articles" instead of what this turned out to be. That'd be cool. I'd like to read more of that. Sounds great.
1. Go to NYJM and select a bunch of articles at random.
2. Read Hill's article.
3. Observe that NYJM papers are all wall-to-wall theoretical math.
4. Observe that Hill's paper has hardly any math at all, and inexplicably ends with an appendix with quotations about male variability, which is itself longer than the elementary "proof" in section 5.
It's simply not a theoretical math paper. Journals have subjects. NYJM's subject is not this.