News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by pjc50 on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:19AM (#17950701)
Quilette is a highly partisan libertarian-right publication and you'd be well advised to treat it as trolling.
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tomhoward on Monday September 10, 2018 @06:50AM (#17950811)
I'm no great devotee of Quillette (I haven't come across an interesting article there for a while), but that's not really a fair characterisation.

It's not "libertarian" in the way Reason magazine is, or "right-wing" in the way that Fox News is.

I think its editors broadly identify as "classical liberals", and they have a stated mission of challenging the "blank-slate" view of human nature.

You can disagree with these positions, but they're legitimate subject areas that reasonable people can discuss, and it deserves better than to be dismissed as you have - even if some of its articles get it wrong, as this one seems to have done.

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by pjc50 on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:50AM (#17951066)
> I think its editors broadly identify as "classical liberals", and they have a stated mission of challenging the "blank slate" view of human nature.

This is incoherent: either you're a believer in something like Locke's "free and equal in the state of nature", or you're not a "classical liberal".

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tomhoward on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:43AM (#17951356)
Adam Smith seemed to see things differently, for what it's worth (about the "blank slate", that is; not about freedom or equality).

I guess the point is we've had ~350 years of scientific discovery and philosophical musings since Locke, and we still don't have simple answers to any of this stuff.

I don't think any serious commentator today (on Quillette or elsewhere) would argue that the existence of some degree of innateness of human nature should pre-determine anyone to a lesser level of freedom or equality or ability to thrive in the world.

I think they'd argue that a better understanding of the former is necessary in order to improve the latter.

At least I would, as someone who has significant skin in the game in terms of my own ability to function.

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by araneae on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:45AM (#17952175)
I'm a little confused by your assertation that therefore we can't dismiss it because it's "classically liberal" rather than "libertarian." I think the point still stands - that they have a very particular perspective, however you choose to define that.

I happen to be sympathetic with a lot of their viewpoints, but it is in fact very axe-grindy. Reason magazine comes off as a lot more reasonable to me than Quillette, despite not being a libertarian, because it's less reactionary.

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tomhoward on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:52AM (#17952640)
My point is that it's not fair or accurate to call describe it as "highly partisan libertarian-right".

I'm with you on the axe-grindiness of Quillette, and since you mention it, that's probably why I don't read it much anymore.

"Libertarian" can mean all kinds of things these days, but in the comment to which I was replying, the description connotes associations with things like: extreme positions against state welfare and gun control, extreme laissez-faire economic policy, social Darwinism, Ayn Rand, the Tea Party, etc.

In my (admittedly limited) experience, these themes seem to appear quite frequently in Reason Magazine, and they certainly do on Fox News.

They aren't a focus for Quillette, however, which in my experience, generally embraces more moderate/centrist (i.e., classical liberal) positions on economic and social issues.

The axe-grindiness to which you refer would stem from the fact that a big part of its raison d'être is to confront what it sees as the ideological corruption of academia.

I agree it can be quite histrionic in its coverage of this issue, and it doesn't hold much interest for me.

But it still matters to demarcate between "highly partisan libertarian-right" and more moderate, sober ideological positions.

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by _dps on Monday September 10, 2018 @03:31PM (#17954426)
I broadly agree with your characterization of Quillette, but I'm curious (genuinely, not in a gotcha way) if you see publications like HuffPo or Vox as similarly having an axe to grind? The thing that makes Quillette stand out IMO is that among many venues with an axe to grind, they get called out for it a lot while publications with equal or worse histories of partisan priorities get a pass as "mainstream web media".
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tomhoward on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:03PM (#17956674)
Yeah I think that's fair.