Can you clarify? Are you saying it is impossible to ascertain the intent of the speaker?
I appreciate the distinction you are making, it is an important one. To lie is to speak a false statement, coupled with the intent to deceive.
What is missing from your assertion is whether we can gage intent and how we do so. Intent is critical to understanding the degree to which we apply a corrective measure. It's the difference between manslaughter and murder.
No, not at all. Just that for something to be a lie it needs 1. to be not true, and 2. for the person uttering it to know that it's not true. Hopefully that's entirely uncontroversial.
Yes, how to find out what people know, desire, plan, intend etc is another question entirely.
Another thing - I don't think you can always neatly divide people's utterances into something they know/believe vs something they don't. e.g. believing in god or not - some have varying levels of belief, depends on mood, some aren't sure what they believe etc, it's often not a simple, unchanging binary 'on or off' situation.
Teacher: What's 8+9? Tommy: Uh..11. Teacher: No, that's a lie!
It seems that particularly in heated political contexts, people enjoy calling false statements lies, and don't notice or care that what they're themselves saying isn't true. The end justifies the means, anything that scores points in the fight is good, even the same or worse than what you're accusing the other guy of doing.
Say Nazis weren't lied too, say all the way up, people really just had these false impressions.
You make decisions that affect others, you're responsible for them. If you made a mistake, used falsehoods as your basis for the decisions, and did atrocious things, or, you did them willingly, I don't know. They're both bad.
If thinking it's a lie pushes you to validate the truthfulness of your knowledge, then so be it. Even if you weren't lied to. It's all about that constant active search for the truth, and a certain amount of challenging what you hear, criticizing the so called facts, and looking a little harder.
Tommy should know better. If he goes on living with that false belief of numbers, he's a threat to society. He'll make wrong choices, miscalculation, and his judgment can't be trusted. The same as if he was a liar.
We should teach people this responsibility. You have to put in the effort to rid yourself of falsehoods and be a truth seeker.
Also, most people should be able to judge their confidence in their knowledge. A lot of people end up doing things even though if they spent a few minutes thinking about it, they would know that they're not sure about this. Yet they do it anyway. That's getting pretty close to a lie.
I know its not the same thing. But I don't see how it matters to the article.
The article is about how falsehoods and lies can cause fear and lead to chaos (amongst other things). Such as what happened in world war 2, where countries turned against each others and targeted Jews.
In that sense, I don't think it matters, you believe Jews are responsible for all your problems and up to get you, so you go commit genocide against them. Does it matter if that idea was a lie or a falsehood? What if Hitler truly believed it? Okay, its a falsehood. So what? He just made a mistake? Everyone makes mistakes?
That's my point. How could all this happen? Suddenly, a falsehood or a lie turned rogue, doesn't matter, but somehow everyone has these ideas, and the whole world starts to act irrationally.
You're a politician, you need to validate your claims before claiming them. You should fact check, have a confidence ratio, justify yourself. You can't just go: "oh sorry, I guess it was false, I just didn't know" after you've already rallied, propagated and enacted laws and decree based on it. But it seems you're trying to claim that spreading falsehoods as a politician isn't as bad as spreading lies. Like if spreading falsehoods was okay. I don't think it is. It's just as bad, and can, and has, lead to great historical atrocities in the past.
A liar does so deliberately and will mix truth with fiction for the goal of manipulation.
Everyone will believe and repeat at least one falsehood, we just don’t know what our own false beliefs are. There is no attempt manipulate with falsehoods.
I think it does a lot of damage in the world, people labelling things as lies when they merely think they're not true. It's very inflammatory. "That's a lie!" says not only "That's not true" but "and you know it". Which often is itself not true. Thus you could be accused of lying yourself.
Very often people are lied to in the media[0], then adopt false beliefs, which they then repeat - but they're not lying when they do so, they believe these things.
It poisons communication when this word 'lies' is thrown around loosely. People disagree about a lot of things. It usually doesn't mean they're lying about it. Usually you have no idea whether people you don't know are lying or saying false things they believe. How could you know that with certainty.
It's not even possible for a sentence to be a lie, in the way you seem to believe. A sentence uttered by a person, yes, but detach it as you did from any speaker, and it can only be true or false. A lie requires specific knowledge in the mind of the particular person uttering the sentence.
[0]Whoops - see, I even did it myself. I don't know if that's right.