Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ...
by Lazare on Sunday September 09, 2018 @07:02PM
(#17948264)
But he wasn't on the Supreme Court when he wrote that earlier opinion, so the earlier opinion tells us nothing about what he'd do if he was on the Court.
In theory we have confirmation hearings to give us some idea of how someone would behave on the Court, but as a practical matter they've never really done that, and in the current partisan environment they certainly don't do that.
Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ...
by lisper on Sunday September 09, 2018 @07:12PM
(#17948297)
So what? He's interviewing for a seat on SCOTUS. So to the OP's question:
> I have to wonder what criteria you believe he should be using to decide his position when answering questions like this.
My answer is: the criteria he should be using are the ones he would apply if he were seated on SCOTUS.
Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ...
by Lazare on Sunday September 09, 2018 @07:17PM
(#17948324)
Are you really arguing that every single judge should decide every single case as if they were on the Supreme Court?
That's 1) not how the system works and 2) not how it really can work.
Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ...
by lisper on Sunday September 09, 2018 @07:54PM
(#17948440)
No, of course not. But that's how I want candidates for the supreme court to answer questions at their confirmation hearings.
Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ...
by Lazare on Sunday September 09, 2018 @11:04PM
(#17949129)
You were replying to someone who said "I have to wonder what criteria you believe he should be using to decide his position when answering questions like this.", but that was referring to the questions he answered when he wrote the mentioned opinion years ago, not questions he answered during the hearing.
Your comment seems misplaced, since we're talking about opinions not confirmation hearings.
The Supreme Court can. That's what the Supreme Court does. It's very simple: what the Patriot act says is irrelevant if the result is "unreasonable" search and seizure. The Supreme Court is the final arbiter of what is "unreasonable". It really is as simple as that.