>Even if the bulk collection of telephony metadata constitutes a search, the Forth Amendment does not bar all searches and seizures. It bars only unreasonable searches and seizures. And the Government’s metadata collection program readily qualifies as reasonable under the Supreme Court’s case law.
He's clearly just enforcing the precedent set by the Supreme Court. When asked whether he'd have written the same thing if the case had occurred after Carpenter vs United States, he answered:
>"Do you think if Carpenter had been decided you would have written the concurrence you did in Klayman?" Leahy asked.
>"I don't see how I could have," Kavanaugh said.
If this one case is all you really need to know about Kavanaugh, then you may as well know the truth rather than a misunderstanding you took away from a single line of news article.
>though judges have, contrary to your opinion, some latitude
This is true, judges have enormous latitude to rule any way they see fit, there are a number of well known 'activist' judges serving today. However good judges understand that they're not legislators and try to enforce the law as accurately as possible.
I don't think you understood what you were reading then. You can't just naively analyse someone applying rules other people wrote, and see any strong evidence in what rules he would write given the opportunity. In some cases (but not this one) a judge will write a side note explaining his thoughts, and even asking for the rules to be changed. But here, we just have someone saying "the Supreme Court said X must lead to Y, and this looks a lot like X, and thus it must lead to Y". The most you can gain from that is an understanding of how he interprets X; you can't learn anything about whether he thinks Y ought to follow X.
[1] https://reason.com/archives/2018/07/18/brett-kavanaughs-four...
This is the organ of government that is meant to apply logic and behave consistently over time. They deal in thick stacks of paper because they consider issues in great depth including the possible ramification and unintended consequences.
There is nuance here and justice is much more complicated than the usual rough-and-tumble politics. This is an ideal opportunity to exercise long form discussion with arguments, large amounts of evidence and a goodwill attitude. Using soundbites damages the system.
Politics is polarized enough these days that you can easily determine based on that single datapoint exact where the political player stands on the spectrum even across other spectrums.
"Kavanaugh went further, saying that even if the Section 215 metadata program was a search, it should be considered 'reasonable' in the name of national security."
To me that's all you really know about this nominee. 4th amendment issues are entirely bound up in precedent (though judges have, contrary to your opinion, some latitude.) But the decision about what is and isn't justified by "national security" is entirely a judgement call by an individual. Kavanaugh's judgement is that the most invasive peacetime spying program in the history of the United States is just fine. That's terrifying.