Re:Lies, Damned Lies, and Medical Science
by pierrefar on Friday October 15, 2010 @09:08AM
(#1794402)
I know what peer review is. And to your point about the demand we make of researchers and the stakes involved, have a read of the Cochrane Collaboration website. Most of their conclusions are "no real evidence, need more studies". It's sobering how much is out there that doesn't stand to really demanding analysis.
1) I think a big point of this article is that the peer review process is misunderstood by the general public (and perhaps many doctors).
More work needs to go into educating the public as to the meaning of scientific studies.2) The scope of money involved in the endeavor is too large to be happy with things just slowly weeding themselves out as is permitted in the OS community.
Higher standards can and should be enforced in all medical studies, an area in which progress is being made but there is a ways to go. Let me push back and say, if the medical research community was exactly like the open source community, we're not asking much of those who are doing the research.