Only if generic type parameters are covariant, if type parameters are invariant, this is not a problem. I guess that most languages with subtypes use invariance by default.
Also, many languages that do generics through monomorphization do not support subclassing (Rust, Haskell, etc.).
no plugins,
Well, there is always the option of boxing collection elements. (E.g. by using Box in Rust.)
(Aside: Type checkers essentially see recursive function definitions as applications of a fixed point operator to non-recursive functions. If your function has a rank-1 type but uses polymorphic recursion, the type checker sees it as the application of a rank-2 fixed point operator to a non-recursive function. This is why I see polymorphic recursion as “morally higher-rank polymorphism”, even when the type signatures in your code are ostensibly rank-1 ones. Polymorphic recursion is widely used in Haskell.)
However, IMO, you only need rank-1 polymorphism 95% of the time anyway, so optimizing for the common use case is a good strategy. By far, the main use case for generics is implementing efficient and reasonably reusable data structures and algorithms in a reasonably type-safe way. For this use case, monomorphization and aggressive inlining of small functions are evidently the right things to do. Other uses of generics (say, streaming I/O frameworks) strike me as a lot more questionable.
To check that, the compiler either has to see all code that will run in the process, which means whole program compilation and no plugins, or the language needs a way to make classes that cannot be subclassed, preventing code that the compiler didn’t see from subclassing T (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_(computer_programming)#N...)