News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by pbhjpbhj on Friday October 15, 2010 @07:16AM (#1794217)
Again, as with your other objection you're defending a invalid statement claimed as a universal truth that is demonstrably false.

>>To receive EM energy you need a structure that's a substantial fraction of the wavelength.

Except you don't and again the point is that it is non-obvious (or at least was) that fractal antennae would work and again this leads us to the position that we shouldn't simply assume we know the truth of extremely complex systems and particularly not based on hand-wavy false statements.

---

Edit: FWIW I don't believe that cell-phones|mobiles cause cancer (generally, though I can imagine there are very specific instances where it might occur and that there are doubtless mechanisms that we don't understand at play).

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by CamperBob on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:53PM (#1796232)
Sigh.

Yes. You're right. You win. Anything will "work" as an antenna at any frequency. You can match your radio's antenna stage to the impedance of a wet noodle, a nerve cell, or an intracellular vacuum cavity with the right network. Whether the antenna ends up electrically distinct from any other object in the vicinity is another question entirely.

As I suggested before I have neither the time nor the qualifications to offer lectures on EM physics, nor to calibrate my words carefully enough to keep them from being recast by verbal anklebiters, so I'll grant you the point.

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by pbhjpbhj on Friday October 15, 2010 @07:12PM (#1796719)
>so I'll grant you the point

Nice verbiage. You should definitely try politics - you appear to accede graciously whilst acceding to something completely ridiculous thus belying your contempt of the result of the argument. I don't want your offered point, I'll take my sensible one instead. Thanks.