News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by rurcliped on Saturday September 08, 2018 @10:51AM (#17941043)
In my area, local journalism had a sharp decline as soon as the publisher began requiring Facebook authentication for comments on the online stories. Previously there had been at least a dozen comments on any major story and now there are always zero. Apparently throwaway accounts can be most critical when the audience is your closest neighbors, especially when a poster is associated with a local business.

(Admittedly, there had been some abuse of the online comments and the publisher did save money in the short term by dropping any moderator effort from the payroll costs.)

Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by gowanus on Saturday September 08, 2018 @11:22AM (#17941185)
It's kind of unfortunate that there's no easy way to scope the internet down to a smaller group of participants, for small time operations like local news sites.

Local news doesn't want to include audience participation from as far away as another time zone, or another state, but even then, geographic exclusions aren't an entirely correct exclusion criteria, since former residents of a local region may wish to participate from afar, because they still tune into home town news, after moving to new territory.

Real world names freeze out lots of participation, because taking ownership of an "incorrect" (contentious) opinion can have permanent consequences to one's reputation.

The real name and/or social credibility fix, is a blunt force trauma solution, to keep out obnoxious people, and isolate discourse to limited subgroups. But another problem is, even without being obnoxious, non-professional participants frequently go off-topic and off-script.

Pseudonyms almost certainly require painstaking, labor intensive moderation, and a skillful attention devoted to selectively ascribing relevance to conversation.

Most local operations just want to know there's an audience with a pulse, but providing that audience with a platform and a voice is another matter entirely.

Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by Eridrus on Saturday September 08, 2018 @11:35AM (#17941250)
One option is to do what illicit sites have done forever: require an invite, such that the bad deeds of the invitee reflect on the inviter. Doesn't require real names on the site, but the inviter knows who they are inviting.
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by scarejunba on Saturday September 08, 2018 @04:06PM (#17942488)
Lobste.rs, for instance
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by wincy on Saturday September 08, 2018 @08:51PM (#17943682)
I want an invitation to lobste.rs now!
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by zie on Saturday September 08, 2018 @10:08PM (#17943923)
message me your email addy.
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by rpvnwnkl on Saturday September 08, 2018 @11:43AM (#17941310)
Facebook Auth is an easy step for web moderators to take, and is helpful from a marketing/analytics perspective as well.

I wonder if requiring a third-party “real person” auth like Facebook wouldn’t be so detrimental (in the contrxt of this discussion) if your user account could be publicly anonymous. For example, the site owners know who you are, but the comments section just sees whatever name/avatar you’ve chosen for that particular site.

A gated community, but you don’t have to wear a name tag once you’re in? I suspect those are already in use, if anyone has examples feel free to share.

Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by gowanus on Saturday September 08, 2018 @01:30PM (#17941812)
For that to work, Facebook Auth would have to raise barriers against open, public identification, while acknowledging that the authenticated account is going to be disclosed to the site owner, which is a confusing layer of deflection.

I don't think the rational basis for the nuance of that negotiation would reach end users or site owners. Both would likely complain that it offers no assurance of safety, and remains a disappointing compromise.

The choice to adopt nuanced tactics in furtherance of rewarding communication requires nuanced personalities at the reigns.

Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by abraham_lincoln on Saturday September 08, 2018 @01:07PM (#17941708)
What about trained moderators?
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by briandear on Saturday September 08, 2018 @02:17PM (#17942028)
Who pays them?
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by st26 on Saturday September 08, 2018 @03:33PM (#17942355)
In my area, Facebook authenticated commenters conducted themselves poorly as ever and comments were permanently switched off.
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by brandonmenc on Saturday September 08, 2018 @10:52PM (#17944083)
Yup. When I look at the comments on the stories the local news back home posts to Facebook, I see hundreds if not thousands of vile racists come out of the woodwork - most of them with names I recognize.
Re:Local News Is Dying, Taking Small Town America With It by KC8ZKF on Saturday September 08, 2018 @08:44PM (#17943661)
Comments are toxic anyway. Disable them and post a link to a subreddit or other place that is willing to deal with them. Or just disable them.