Re:ZestCash is Not Good.
by plorkyeran on Friday October 15, 2010 @12:17AM
(#1793677)
It suggests that the awesome people with backgrounds in crappy jobs got out of the crappy jobs because they're awesome, rather than being awesome because they did crappy jobs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ZestCash is Not Good.
by andrewljohnson on Friday October 15, 2010 @12:31PM
(#1795163)
If you only look at the set of people who work in white collar jobs, I would wager those who previously had blue-collar jobs exhibit some positive characteristics.
I don't think that the set of all people who have had or currently have a blue-collar job is particularly relevant to the argument, other than as a backdrop for speculation.
Correlation is not causation. You could just as easily interpret his statement as P(CJ|A) > P(CJ|~A): the conditional probability that someone had a crappy job at some point in their life given that they're awesome is higher than the conditional probability they did given that they aren't.