News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by Silhouette on Thursday October 14, 2010 @10:57PM (#1793529)
> I once had a case come to me after some homeowners had lost at trial in a dispute with their mortgage lender over some technical provisions of their mortgage. The amount at stake was perhaps a couple of hundred thousand dollars. However, on losing, the court awarded the lender almost $400K in fees (it did so under a contract provision providing that the prevailing party in any dispute would receive an award of such fees).

The problem here wasn't the fact that the loser wound up paying the court fees.

The real problems started with hearing the case on a planet where FOUR HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS in legal fees was considered reasonable for any court case, and where apparently a contract provision stating this was considered enforceable rather than struck down as manifestly unreasonable.

This was compounded by hearing the case in a region on that planet where the appeals system comes with a price tag of several years' salary.

Costs are supposed to be just that: the cost of bringing a case to court. That means things like paying to build courthouses and paying a salary to those who run the courts (from the judges to the janitors) and, yes, even paying a reasonable rate to the lawyers. If your courts are ever awarding more than that in costs, no matter what the outcome of the case, then your legal system is broken.

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by jbooth on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:24PM (#1795607)
Here's the thing. It wasn't the normal people who paid 400k for some lawyers. That was the bank's legal fee.

So if you have loser pays, and you're a megacorp, spending 6-figures defending every lawsuit becomes a great move. Enhances your chances of winning since you're pitting a department of lawyers against whoever the plaintiff could retain, and then assuming your department of lawyers wins, you don't even have to pay for them. Totally broken economics which incentivize overdefending with a huge team of lawyers on every single case.

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by Silhouette on Friday October 15, 2010 @07:31PM (#1796782)
> It wasn't the normal people who paid 400k for some lawyers. That was the bank's legal fee.

I realise that it's the big organisation fees we're talking about, but please understand that even here in the UK, it is not automatic that the loser pays, it is just the default result most of the time. Please see my other post.

> So if you have loser pays, and you're a megacorp, spending 6-figures defending every lawsuit becomes a great move.

Only if you permit unlimited and arbitrarily disproportionate costs. No-one says you have to do that, even if you require or default to the loser paying.

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by jbooth on Saturday October 16, 2010 @10:31AM (#1798004)
Well, we're already at a much higher level of detail of implementation than the article even thought of approaching or than most of the supporters of this policy have likely thought through.

I'd just like to note that.

Further, good luck getting any consumer protection aspects through congress. The only way this happens is as a giveaway to large corporations.