Of course, the smart company has a defense against this tactic: only use the funds provided by the opponent. This would eventually bankrupt the frivolous lawsuit trolls, since it would cost them real money to continue the case at the risk of losing it all while costing the defendant nothing.
The more I think about it, the more this seems like a system that provides an incentive to only sue when you have a legitimate claim. Anything else wouldn't be worth the risk for either side.
On the other hand BigCorp which stands to lose a claimed $10m in the unlikely event of losing the suit needs to retain the services of a lawyer, which will probably not be a cheap one as they have a lot more at stake.
So BigCorp will certainly need to put enough money into the pot to cover their own expenses, and the troll will pocket half of that even if the case gets thrown out.
A solvable problem, I think. If I have to pay myself $50 an hour to represent my cause, it only hurts me if my cause isn't legitimate.
Or maybe set some threshold for legal expenses; the system could work as it does now up to a maximum, then a pay pool is implemented.
The obvious problem with our system is that the party with the deepest pockets can drag a case out until the opposing party cries uncle and gives up.
There's a simple solution that seems fair; both sides pay into a pool for legal representation and the pool is divided equally. So if Megacorp wants to sue Joe's Startup, Joe can afford the same representation that Megacorp can.
I'm sure there are downsides to that system that I'm not thinking about, but it seems like it would be pretty fair.