> More importantly, why do we want this? What benefits does this bring? I don't see many for the ordinary person.
Maybe it could shift liability? So if someone posts the lyrics to a song and Sony sues them for 50,000 euro could they argue that it is the fault of the ISP for not filtering their post properly?
This is a longshot, but I was trying very hard to think of some way in which this law doesn't screw over individuals for the benefit of large corporations.
... this would not impact smaller SaaS companies ...
This isn't a law yet and I don't think most people want it to become one.
That said, I disagree that this isn't a terrible burden for the small guy. Even if it would be trivial to set up, all the other downsides remain and it leads to lock-in in the form of dependence on large companies who have implemented this.
More importantly, why do we want this? What benefits does this bring? I don't see many for the ordinary person.