News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ancient farmers spared us from glaciers but changed Earth... by coldtea on Friday September 07, 2018 @09:35AM (#17934074)
If indeed ancient farmers (that were like 1/100 our population) already had "profoundly changed Earth's climate", so much for the "human activity couldn't be the reason for climate change today" argument...
Re:Ancient farmers spared us from glaciers but changed Earth... by wavefunction on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:31AM (#17934513)
Well the argument that human activity isn't the reason for climate change isn't completely ruled out by this historical evidence but I think it provides compelling evidence that only the dishonest can disregard.
Re:Ancient farmers spared us from glaciers but changed Earth... by danjoc on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:35PM (#17936600)
Logically speaking, this is incorrect. Both could be true given a circumstance, like say, the sun goes red giant in the later case.

Furthermore, "the reason" can usually be whatever you want it to be if you go far enough back in the chain of causations. My hands were wet this morning when I dropped the jelly jar. But that wasn't my fault, it was the water company's fault for supplying the wetness on my hands. Or perhaps it was the Roman's fault for kickstarting the whole thing with aqueducts. But that's really just mankind's fault for existing, so human activity is at fault for my loose grip on the jelly jar today.

Overall, I found this article interesting, and frankly: Go mankind! We averted an ice age and certain death/destruction with farming. If we want to talk about problematic climate change, look at how living on top of a mile of ice works out for our species.

Re:Ancient farmers spared us from glaciers but changed Earth... by empath75 on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:07AM (#17934816)
nobody making those arguments is making them in good faith and no amount of evidence will stop them from making it.
Re:Ancient farmers spared us from glaciers but changed Earth... by coldtea on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:29AM (#17935025)
Bad faith means not believing what you say ("with the intention of deceiving someone or doing harm").

One could very well imagine (and some of us actually know) people that legitimately believe that the climate change we're through is not man made -- they say it cause they believe it, they don't try to knowingly deceive anyone.

It's another thing to say something because you do not trust scientists (including scientific consensus) because e.g. you believe that they extrapolate from incomplete data and not enough understanding, or to prefer this or that fringe researcher to the majority opinion, and another to be in bad faith.

Re:Ancient farmers spared us from glaciers but changed Earth... by specialist on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:04PM (#17936822)
I now believe, but cannot prove, that most people's professed beliefs are not rational, logical, reality-based, sensical.

Rather, beliefs appear to be more about identity, virtue signaling, and tribal acceptance.

If true, reason is impotent. To change belief systems, one must use psychology, rhetoric, propaganda, evangelism.

The lesswrong.com crowd is calling this "belief as attire". I don't know what to call "Popperian beliefs" (true until proven false) vs "aspirational beliefs" (make our own reality).

My greatest fear is that my self-image of being a Popperian is actually just aspirational.