News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Blocks Spotify in the U.S. by Tycho on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:13PM (#1793320)
I kinda thought they were always planning on Premium charges though, they just wanted to build some momentum first. My main problem with it is I can see 'the rights-holders' making a good new revenue stream, but only in the sense of people/companies that own massive publishing catalogs. The individual rights-holders, eg. the songwriters, I fear are being sold up the river.
Re:Apple Blocks Spotify in the U.S. by mzl on Friday October 15, 2010 @01:22AM (#1793758)
I was in the original beta-trials of Spotify (started second half of 2007), and the info then seemed to indicate that the intended model was ad-financed. A lot of people apparently asked about paying to get rid of the ads.

As for smaller artists, compare it with the situation in commercial radio. A few radio-plays will not get you very much money, but the number of people that listened to your song is actually quite high.

Re:Apple Blocks Spotify in the U.S. by Tycho on Friday October 15, 2010 @11:39AM (#1794921)
Comparing it to radio is where the trouble starts. A potential customer cannot rely upon radio to access your music/product. At best they'll hear a few of the artist's tracks, if they're patient and lucky. Therefore the radio is in no way a substitute for owning the LP, it's more like an advert/complement than a competing service. But Spotify DOES let the potential customer access your product in full, removing the main incentive to buy your LP. Furthermore, you're not only competing with a free version of your own product, your competing with a vast catalog of other music, millions of records that can be accessed effortlessly. "Should I spend £10 on this one album, or should I spend £10 for a month of unlimited access to endless high-quality music?" The economic position this puts individual artists in is dire.

Also, another thing about the ads is sometimes they're hardly ads at all, they're just Spotify announcements. I can't believe they'd be wasting spots like that if they were really pulling in serious advertising money.