News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by SoftwareMaven on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:11PM (#1793313)
While certainly catastrophic, this is anecdotal at best, and similar anecdotes can be found for the companies with deep pockets using their lawyers to suck individuals dry. Unfortunately, these are the scare-type comments that keep any reform from happening.

If the US became a less litigious country as a result of loser-pay, then the system would be a benefit, IMO. The legal tax required to do business in the US is too high.

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by joe_the_user on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:47PM (#1793376)
"this is anecdotal at best"

Considering someone did just tell the anecdote, I'd say this is anecdotal at the very least. I've read about various abuses revolving around the Texas court system requireing the bond-posting Grellas mentioned.

But I'm too tired to google-up any link, so I've leave it "anecdotal" too.

The "legal tax" in the US is high but lowering it is hard when so many parties want to spin an advantage out of said lowering.

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by ZeroGravitas on Friday October 15, 2010 @04:59AM (#1794013)
I think it's anecdotal at best because it's a lawyer (I believe) relating it, in an issue that clearly pits lawyers against everyone else in terms of who gains and loses financially from this change. And it doesn't actually apply to loser pays, but some random contract provision within a different system.

You don't even have to assume malice, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by jbooth on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:22PM (#1795597)
This issue is very much not about pitting lawyers vs everyone else. It's about pitting people/corporations likely to be sued against people/corporations who might sue someday.
Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by sgift on Friday October 15, 2010 @05:16AM (#1794036)
> If the US became a less litigious country as a result of loser-pay, then the system would be a benefit, IMO. The legal tax required to do business in the US is too high.

To put it the other way around: Loser-Pay makes it easier for companies to screw people over. Which is exactly what happens here in Germany, where companies can pull shady tricks without fear of getting sued - the risk of having to pay all the fees is too high for the everyman.

Loser-pay sounds good in theory, but sucks in practice.

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by Calamitous on Friday October 15, 2010 @08:48AM (#1794355)
> Loser-Pay makes it easier for companies to screw people over.

And this is not the case now?

Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by camiller on Friday October 15, 2010 @10:14AM (#1794565)
Correct, now it is only easy, loser pays makes it ridiculously easy.
Re:Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work... by jbooth on Friday October 15, 2010 @02:19PM (#1795588)
Anecdotal at best, sure, but did you read the linked article?

"Ok so some courts in europe use this procedure. I could talk about it, explain how it's viewed and how it works in those societies, perhaps elucidate on the differences in legal systems and social contract between the US and europe... orrrrrrrrr I could note some liberal nobody's heard of supported it once and call current day liberals hypocrites even though most of them have never even put thought into this concept. Oh, and beefeaters! Good old England."