News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by pbhjpbhj on Thursday October 14, 2010 @08:31PM (#1793215)
>>Absolutely nothing happens when you microwave a glass of water that wouldn't also happen if you heated it on the stove, or put it under a heat lamp.

I'd like to see someone superheat water on the stove or indeed boil water inside a block of ice under a heat lamp.

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by CamperBob on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:45PM (#1793372)
Yeah. Superheating. That's what must be causing all these new cases of cancer that have appeared since people began using hand-held cellular phones in the late 1980s.

/rolls eyes

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by pbhjpbhj on Friday October 15, 2010 @07:12AM (#1794212)
>>Absolutely nothing happens when you microwave a glass of water that wouldn't also happen [...]

You can roll your eyes all you like it won't make that true.

The parent made a general statement for which I believe there to be clear factual objection which I mentioned. The only logical contradiction would be to show the falsehood of such objection. I did consider saying "obviously this isn't the mechanism here" but I think the take-away is that you shouldn't make universal statements that are obviously false.

This does actually then have a bearing on the matter in hand. If the universal is false then it opens the path for other unknown mechanisms to be considered that may also contradict such a universal statement. If people are willing to make such demonstrably false claims at such a low level then trusting them to clearly and accurately present the more complex situations becomes extremely difficult [for me].

Perhaps I'm unique in this but if you lie to me about one thing then I'm disinclined to believe you about another.