Re:Why investing in bit.ly last week was a bad idea
by tptacek on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:40PM
(#1793111)
What's the bargain Libya struck up with the IETF/IANA regarding delegations under .LY?
Re:Why investing in bit.ly last week was a bad idea
by jrockway on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:59PM
(#1793154)
Maintaining records so that delegation to the owner of a domain happens. VB.LY owns VB.LY. LY stopped delegating.
This breaks the Internet.
Re:Why investing in bit.ly last week was a bad idea
by tptacek on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:34PM
(#1793356)
This exact same argument says that Namecheap should lose its registrar status for "breaking the internet" when people don't pay to renew their domains.
Similarly, if Apple ever made the mistake of setting up an NS record pointing JROCKWAY.APPLE.COM to your nameserver, they'd be "breaking the internet" to change their mind.
The reality is that there is no technical difference at all between LY. and APPLE.COM.
When you choose to use the root nameserver, you are assuming they are making good decisions about who to delegate to. When COM. delegates to Apple's servers for APPLE.COM., that's a good decision. When the root nameserver delegates to the current LY. servers, that's a bad decision, because LY. does not hold up their end of the bargain and properly delegate. VB.LY. should delegate to VB.LY.'s servers. But for some reason, they refuse to do it. So the root server should simply not delegate to it.
Incidentally, nobody is forcing anyone to use "the" root nameservers. If you want vb.ly back, just use a different root!