Now for your second point: all-purpose legal insurance doesn't seem like something that the poor are going to have bought. Even if the poor were rational and outrageously well-informed, the chance that any given person will be subject to discrimination is so low as to probably make the administrative costs of such insurance too large. However, if you could buy insurance after been discriminated against, then this could solve the problem. It's basically what I suggested in my top-level comment (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1792791), only it's an outside agency rather than the plantiff's lawyer which takes on the risk. It's not clear to me which format the economic frictions will favor.
Do you know if this kind of case-specific insurance is available in countries with the loser-pays rule?
If I'm understanding you correctly, you're suggesting something like a fire insurance that you can buy when your house has already burnt down? If so, no I know of no companies who offer such a thing, and I would be quite surprised if they existed.
This sort of legal cost insurance works the same way as other insurances. The one I took out a few years ago stipulated that it didn't cover any existing disputes, not disputes that would arise in the (I think) 3 first months of the insurance; just like some insurances don't cover existing problems.
This sort of insurance is also not as common as the article makes it appear, and it was even quite rare when the article was written (1995). In 2008, under 50% of Dutch households had a legal assistance insurance of some form (I think this number includes the optional parts of car insurances where you are insured against claims arising from accidents, but I'm not sure on this; I suspect the majority of insurances to be in this area, and thus the amount of insurances against civil cases to be lower). The last 10 years there have been double-digit increases in the amount of people who have such insurances, so it's really something of the last decade.
No, it would be like buying fire insurance during a small fire that would only payout if your house burned down completely. The insurance guy would arrive, examine the fire, and determine that it had a 90% of being stopped with most of the house intact, and a 10% chance of destroying everything. Then, he would calculated how much you would need to replace your house in the case of complete destruction, and model the premiums accordingly.
>The last 10 years there have been double-digit increases in the amount of people who have such insurances, so it's really something of the last decade.
But the poor are going to be the last people to get such insurance.
0.9 x 40% x $110,000 + 0.1 x (-$10,000 - $10,000 (his own opportunity cost)) = +$37,600 expected gain
In fact, the "lower pays" rule works in favor of the poor person (and their lawyer) in this example.Of course, if the case were a lot weaker, it wouldn't help. As for your question regarding insurance, I know nothing about the European legal system besides what I learned from this article.
Are you saying that this is worse than the existing system or worse than a theoretical system in which poor people can somehow initiate a suit with no money?
And since it never went to trial they can of course sue him again and cost him (or anyone else) the same amount next time he writes anything.
But the biggest difference is that our society simply isn't litigious and I don't know which is the cause and which is the effect.
"One way Europeans have adapted to the residual risks of loser-pays has been through personal legal expense insurance, which covers a variety of legal risks including that of finding oneself a plaintiff in a lawsuit. The aggrieved party takes his case to his insurer, which, if it finds the case strong, provides a lawyer and absorbs the risk of owing the opponent a fee....If the insurer screens cases carefully, it will collect more in fees for its lawyer than it will pay to winning opponents."
I don't know if these claims are true, having no experience with European legal systems. If true, they would appear to address your criticisms.