News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by coldtea on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:13AM (#17925378)
>This reads in places like a developer or publisher who has grown accustomated to stuffing his pages with gobs and gobs of javascript and questionable UI patterns and is now outraged at the prospect that someone wants to take that privilege away from him. I can't agree with that.

Well, it's not your job to agree with that or not though. He should be free to do as he pleases (so, the freedom to spew gobs of JS etc. should be unarguable) and you should be free to not visit his page.

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by ben_w on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:21AM (#17925417)
Should they be free to spew gobs of JS?

The average person can’t tell in advance — or, often, after the event — that this will happen, and when it does happen it is bad for them.

Aside from the security issues, the current status quo shortens battery life, wastes bandwidth (which is still precious and limited on mobile, even if not on landlines), and is generally done for the benefit of everyone except the user.

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by coldtea on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:43AM (#17925520)
>Should they be free to spew gobs of JS? The average person can’t tell in advance — or, often, after the event — that this will happen, and when it does happen it is bad for them.

If they can tell in advance, they can tell it after, and punish the page by not visiting it.

If they can't tell it after the event, then it shouldn't matter.

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by ben_w on Thursday September 06, 2018 @11:09AM (#17926812)
Analogy time: Which cigarette gives you cancer?

If they didn’t kill you by cancer and heart disease, but instead one in 1.4 million exploded and blew your head off, you’d know. Everyone would. The most explody brand would be punished.

The constant bit-by-bit risk of 1.4 cigarettes per micromort makes it ignorable, even though the risk is identical.

The only website I punish for their JavaScript content at the moment is forbes.com, and that’s because they have a combination of an adblock-blocker and (whenever I tried turning it off to read a story someone linked me to) ads which redirect me to scams.

That’s dynamite.

On my laptop I disable JavaScript everywhere unless it’s important to enable. I would do the same on my phone except the UI makes switching it in and off on a per-site basis much more annoying. The result is my phone battery, which can trivially record GPS traces all day while also managing day-to-day use of augmented reality translation all with negligible battery use, runs out of battery in a few hours of browsing.

That’s cigarettes.

Which site(s) killed the battery?

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by xg15 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:50AM (#17925557)
> If they can't tell it after the event, then it shouldn't matter.

Ah yes, the famous strategy for solving all problems: Hiding them, because if no one notices them anymore, they are not problems anymore.

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by coldtea on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:56AM (#17925584)
Isn't that the definition of empiricism and/or utilitarianism?

If something doesn't impact someone in a way that they can ever tell, it is not a problem to them.

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by xg15 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:46AM (#17925541)
> ... and you should be free to not visit his page.

You mean restrict myself to the remaining two websites that don't do this?

Also, it's not like the website obesity crisis is a new concept: http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by rjmunro on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:37AM (#17925492)
In that case Google should be free to not index his page, or at least not show it to users who Google know are not interested in downloading it.
Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by coldtea on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:43AM (#17925527)
>In that case Google should be free to not index his page

No, it shouldn't. Google should reflect an accurate ranking of pages based on content relevance (as best as possible technically), not a curated list.

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by Isofarro on Thursday September 06, 2018 @09:47AM (#17926207)
If the metrics Google collect indicate that visitors prefer quickly loading pages, that should be factored into the decision as what external resources to link out to.

The evidence that visitors find bloated pages an issue is slowly growing, from Amazon quantising the financial loss of slower loading pages [1], to more recently, Life Hacks taking advantage of GDPR-triggered quicker-loading less-bloated European-versions of news sites [2].

I guess the question worth asking is if a non-AMP page is objectively more-performant than an AMP version, does Google prefer the publisher to keep the slower AMP version?

In a sense AMP is user-focused, validating Jakob Nielsen's prediction of the end of Web Design, because "people spend more time on other sites" [3].

[1] https://www.fastcompany.com/1825005/how-one-second-could-cos... [2] https://lifehacker.com/to-make-websites-load-faster-browse-t... [3] https://www.nngroup.com/articles/end-of-web-design/

Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by PurpleBoxDragon on Thursday September 06, 2018 @01:13PM (#17927729)
Is Google not a private company that can do what it wants? If they wish to offer a curated list, is that not their choice to make?
Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by xg15 on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:55AM (#17925574)
Why is Google held to a different standard here?
Re:Google wants websites to adopt AMP as the default for bui... by coldtea on Thursday September 06, 2018 @08:22AM (#17925683)
Because, as it constitutes an effective monopoly on search (monopoly doesn't mean "absolutely sole mean". There were other OSes besides Windows in the 90s too, and other telcos when Bell split (e.g. MCI)), it's ranking has enormous influence over news, information gathering, business, politics, and so on.

Too much to be left to some private interests to play with at their own opaque will (and sell to the highest bidder).