News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by roc on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:01PM (#1792354)
Important fact 2: No study has ever shown a correlation between the rise in cell phone usage and any rise in cancer rates.

If there were some unknown indirect method by which cell phone radiation causes cancer, where is all the cancer? Because no study has ever found it.

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by btilly on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:24PM (#1792434)
That fact is far, far weaker than the other. It turns out that many types of cancer don't start to show up in the epidemiology for periods of 20 years or so. Well known examples include lung cancer from smoking and various cancer rates among those exposed to nuclear bombs.

Based on that if cellphones cause cancer, the odds are very low that we would have noticed yet.

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by g_lined on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:42PM (#1793116)
15 years ago, Danish researchers completed a 13 year study of over 400,000 mobile phone users and found no increased cancer risk. So there has been enough time for that data to start to show itself.

http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/content/93/3/203.abstract?ijk...

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by CamperBob on Thursday October 14, 2010 @06:18PM (#1792879)
Cell phones have easily been in use for 20 years, and handheld radios have been in use for far longer than that, at far higher power levels.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by Groxx on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:39PM (#1793109)
I don't recall hearing how everyone had a handheld radio stuck to their head for substantial amounts of time every day, as cell phones have today.

Radiation damage, if it occurs, is cumulative. I'd be willing to bet that the heavier-use side of cell phone users have encountered far more radiation from their phones than a similar fraction of handheld radio users, even before accounting for the difference in proximity (phones = inches at best, radios = inches at minimum) which would give radiation from radios exponentially less radiation than they emit compared to phones.

(not that I'm claiming they do cause cancer. Merely that the handheld radio side of the argument doesn't really work)

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by CamperBob on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:55PM (#1793390)
Radiation damage, if it occurs, is cumulative.

"I don't know what effect I'm talking about, exactly, but I'm sure it's cumulative."

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by Groxx on Thursday October 14, 2010 @11:55PM (#1793652)
I can tell you've typed, but all I'm seeing is idiocy and an attempted insult thinly disguised as snark.

Radiation damage, ie anything not from excess energy in the area causing injury like burns, but referring to genetic damage, is rather obviously cumulative if you consider it for more time than it took you to type that out.

Genetic damage cannot be repaired. At best, the offending cell is killed. At worst, it divides and spreads its damaged code, sometimes becoming cancerous.

Cancers frequently come from mutations. Radiation damage causes random mutations. Put 1 and 1 together, and you get an increased risk of cancers based exclusively off the sum total of radiation received, ignoring any time dimension.

Look at any studies looking for "safe radiation doses", or consider why people don't snuggle up to radium-glowing blankets every night, or take a peek at why revigators are banned, or why you don't want radon in your basement; you'll see the same information pop up every time. Radiation is cumulative. Small amounts for a long time are just as dangerous as large amounts for a short time, except they don't cause burns.

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by CamperBob on Friday October 15, 2010 @05:46PM (#1796416)
Yeah. Because it's not as if there are different kinds of radiation, or anything.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by Groxx on Friday October 15, 2010 @11:15PM (#1797226)
And the dangers of these multiple kinds of radiation are...?

Damage to cells and damage to DNA. One is repaired.

Modifying protein structures results in one of the above, as does causing higher energy molecular interactions potentially causing abnormal chemicals for a particular area. We've now covered every effect radiation can have on your body. One is guaranteed permanent and thus cumulative. One is not, and is only dangerous in higher degrees, and by the time that gets high enough to kill you, you've suffered massive genetic damage and will probably die anyway from cancers.

All this of course is ignoring the possibility of radiation creating prions. I've heard of no studies which have found this to be the case, so I don't include it. And they cause cellular or genetic damage as well, so they're still accounted for, just more remotely.

The different kinds of radiation effectively just determine how much damage (energy of the particle / wave) and how far they penetrate. ie, alpha particles typically only penetrate up to a few centimeters, but have massively more energy, while gamma rays can easily pass through you entirely, with beta particles roughly in between.

Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by carbocation on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:02PM (#1792362)
I actually considered making that fact #1, since I personally consider it to be more convincing. At any rate, we agree.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by cynest on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:09PM (#1792388)
Playing the devil's advocate here, but wouldn't exposure rates be more important than usage? Most people would likely be exposed more to other phone's radiation than just their own phone's.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by aphyr on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:23PM (#1792433)
Inverse square law. Radiation from a phone 10 cm from your brain is 100 times more intense than radiation from your friend's phone a meter away.
Re:"Physics shows that cell phones cannot cause cancer" by cynest on Thursday October 14, 2010 @08:05PM (#1793168)
However, a person often in crowded areas will likely experience far more radiation over time simply from others around them on their cell phones.