And attributing it to malice is truly naive pessimistic thinking.
The reality is that both of those positions exist. There are people in government (and anywhere) that want to help or hurt people. I find transparency more helpful than hurtful, because we are in an age where there are public repercussions for visible actions.
Rights and justice are based upon the same assumptions - no you can't take the prosecution's word that they are totally guilty because they look shifty and aren't from around here! They have to prove that there was a crime and that they committed it beyond a reasonable doubt.
Until they can prove say secure communication in itself can kill anyone in the world like a magic spell they have no case for this.
Pessimism is thus wise in the same sense that you shouldn't ask a stranger on the street to hold your wallet for half an hour.
There are hundreds of thousands of people with top secret clearance for fucks sake. They're not all part of some conniving cabal.
The output of the machine is what matters. If the output of the machine is bad, then everybody that is a part of it is and unwitting bad actor.
We have to make sure we don't make bad public policy machines.
My government is literally killing refugees in order to make a public statement that seeking asylum in our country is worse than staying in a country where you face death from bombs, lynch mobs or government execution.
I think my interpretation of this Five Eyes directive as a lazy power grab is being extremely kind to the people involved because I'm implying they have a plan and are aware of what they are doing.
This is not true at all. That is the smoke screen they have put up, but the real intent is to institute pervasive surveillance and have more power over people. They're lazy and have decided that defeating encryption is the easiest way to bypass the effort required to investigate crimes properly.
Attributing this policy drive to altruism is truly naive wishful thinking.