Re:Publish your computer code: it is good enough
by pama on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:58AM
(#1790587)
Agreed. Sharing these big, mature, foundation frameworks is essential for the reproducibility of published research. The additional convenience scripts that accompany a paper are often described or provided in the methods and supplement. As a reviewer, I block papers that lack unambiguous information allowing their reproduction, but I don't penalize the lack of explicit convenience scripts, since these can be reproduced or provided from the authors upon request.
The code actually corresponding to a given paper is likely to be a small amount that builds on packages such as those above, or products like Matlab, whatever. There could be code to implement an experiment, and Matlab code to analyze the data.