Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by Dylanlacey on Thursday October 14, 2010 @11:06PM
(#1793550)
'...but for them it was just "another language" that they used, not "the language"'
This is the case for almost EVERY great developer: They're language agnostic. The language is never important.
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by rb2k_ on Friday October 15, 2010 @03:20AM
(#1793894)
yes, that's what I was trying to express
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by InclinedPlane on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:20AM
(#1790233)
Worse than being verbose, Java is limited. It doesn't have the barely insulated connection to the bare metal of the machine that C/C++ has (allowing you to do damn near anything if you code it well enough) because Java is designed to be "safe". But on the other hand it doesn't have any of the more sophisticated programming techniques like first class functions (and thus higher order functions, etc.) The result is a language which requires cumbersome patterns (often inexpertly applied) just to get any regular work done. Stuff that in more sophisticated languages could be refactored down to elegant systems.
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by tkahn6 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:57AM
(#1790183)
I think it's because Java is just plain and simple a boring language.
I agree for the most part. I make my college programming projects fun by finding uses for the Reflections API.
Check out 'invoke'. http://download.oracle.com/javase/1.4.2/docs/api/java/lang/r...
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by rb2k_ on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:14AM
(#1790216)
That's cool, but the sad part is that this is a common feature with most other languages and not just some added library. Still great that you show what's possible :)
Also: does anybody know why Java core classes don't have examples in the documentation? (compare: http://ruby-doc.org/core/classes/String.html )
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by brazzy on Thursday October 14, 2010 @11:03AM
(#1791113)
Um... reflection is a core feature of Java, and has been since Java 1.1
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by rb2k_ on Friday October 15, 2010 @03:27AM
(#1793903)
Oh sorry then, I don't use Java a lot these days...
It just seemed weird to me that I had to include it. I'm used to this functionality being available without any additional steps because it is implemented in something like an "Object" class.
(Lots of Ruby these days)
Re:I think I figured out why good Java developers are so har...
by megamark16 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @11:19AM
(#1791182)
A coworker and I were just talking about this, and we decided that it was probably due to the fact that a lot of documentation in Java and .NET is auto generated based on the code comments, which are highly standardized and strictly enforced. Most languages have tools for generating documentation based on code comments, but in Java and .NET you usually end up with a lot of "Here's the signature of the constructor for this class, and here's a list of methods and members." It's lame, and often pretty useless.
Most people would agree that Java is a tad verbose and over-patternized. It doesn't do any "fancy" stuff like functional programming, it doesn't have a lot of "sexy" libraries and the community arround it is pretty much stuck in a fixed big-enterprise mindset ("I don't care that it's easier to do it with tool x or y! We can't maintain anything else but Z!") and a lot of Java developers have only experiences with Java which limits the way they try to solve problems.
The worst example of this was when I had to witness a friend of mine having to code a prototype for a handheld device in Apache Struts because "that's what we know and we can enhance if you're not there". He had to basically implement most UI interactions in Javascript so it was even close to usable.
If you would ask any Ruby/Python/Scala/Erlang/... developer about other languages or new technologies (noSQL databases, node.js, ...), chances are they will at least know something about it because they love their craft. Most "only Java" people I've met so far simply aren't particularly interested in anything that isn't directly related to their work.
p.s. this doesn't mean that there aren't great developers that use Java, I've met some amazing people that are fluent in Java, but for them it was just "another language" that they used, not "the language".