News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reinventing the Wheel: Why no-tech ancient civilizations ... by mattmanser on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:38AM (#1790152)
This article makes absolutely no sense.

China was technologically more advanced once. As was the Middle East. The Mayans. We could go on listing 'peoples' who were at one point technologically advanced but are now way behind economically.

This is just mistaking the effect of accumulated capital for technology. This is just wrong on so many levels, so obviously wrong.

Re:Reinventing the Wheel: Why no-tech ancient civilizations ... by dan00 on Thursday October 14, 2010 @07:06AM (#1790491)
"This is just mistaking the effect of accumulated capital for technology."

And how do you accumulate capital? By hammering on stones?

Re:Reinventing the Wheel: Why no-tech ancient civilizations ... by CWuestefeld on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:11AM (#1790732)
China was technologically more advanced once.

This doesn't work as a counterexample, because they are once again one of the world's largest economies.

As was the Middle East.

I wonder how (the absolute lack of) natural resources figures into this. Also, Easterly notes the terrible impact that bad leadership can have (indeed, I think that was a major sub-point of the article). And considering all the wars there, I'm guessing that a real infrastructure based on that technology can't accrete very deeply.

About the Mayans, I don't know enough...

Re:Reinventing the Wheel: Why no-tech ancient civilizations ... by Symmetry on Thursday October 14, 2010 @10:16AM (#1790939)
The Mayas compared well with the ancient Greeks in many areas but were still stone age some. If you're looking at contemporary comparisons they support the article's point.
Re:Reinventing the Wheel: Why no-tech ancient civilizations ... by cturner on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:58AM (#1790304)
He's picking a particular point in time, and saying that this was important, not that it's a 500 year window that shifts continuously.