Re:US Court of Appeals: An IP address isn't enough to identi...
by realusername on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:30AM
(#17901487)
If you put a law like this, why even have a justice system? Either you are guilty of piracy or you are guilty of not securing enough your computer.
Having a case where you are guilty whatever you say makes no sense, especially for something where the damages to society are very abstract and not proven, like piracy.
Re:US Court of Appeals: An IP address isn't enough to identi...
by dragonwriter on Monday September 03, 2018 @05:37AM
(#17901509)
It's possible to actually nor have your computer used in piracy, and the justice system would still be about proving whether it was. Also, even if there was liability for negligence in security contributing to piracy, it might be lesser than for willful piracy itself.
The law suggested may be bad, but it doesn't remove the role of the justice system in determine the existence and degree of liability.
Re:US Court of Appeals: An IP address isn't enough to identi...
by squirrelicus on Monday September 03, 2018 @01:48PM
(#17903924)
Interesting. I've never heard this before. Id love to see some statutes or cases here, because it's not clear to me. This behavior isn't unheard of in my neck of the woods
Re:US Court of Appeals: An IP address isn't enough to identi...
by chronial on Monday September 03, 2018 @02:03PM
(#17904005)
I can't help you regarding the US. I live in Germany and there's a law (§15 StVO) that says "The driver of a vehicle must take the necessary precautions to prevent accidents and disturbances to traffic when they exit the vehicle. Vehicles also have to be secured against unauthorized use."
I had a quick google and I found mentions that you will get fines for this. I did not find an example of something bad happening with an unlocked car.
It is not that simple if you left your car unlocked. Leaving an unlocked car around with the key in the ignition is clearly a public danger.