Re:20M historical artifacts destroyed in Brazil National Mus...
by Alex3917 on Monday September 03, 2018 @10:22AM
(#17902710)
> By spreading collections around into N locations, you would have, on average, N times more fires like this one, but fire would be engulfing a smaller collection at a time (1/N)
If the likelihood of a fire starting in a non-residential building is roughly proportional to the square footage of the building, then you'd have roughly the same total number of fires across all buildings but 1/N of the collection destroyed each time.
Re:20M historical artifacts destroyed in Brazil National Mus...
by skookumchuck on Monday September 03, 2018 @04:17AM
(#17901221)
That would only be true if the risk of fire is evenly distributed, which it obviously isn't, and that a museum burning down now and then would not motivate better protections for the rest.
In any case, the strategy they chose obviously didn't work and they lost it 100%.
Re:20M historical artifacts destroyed in Brazil National Mus...
by knlinux on Monday September 03, 2018 @04:52AM
(#17901357)
It probably isn’t but it’s safe to assume that this location was at least around the median in terms of fire risk (this location had probably better infrastructure than the average Brazilian city), so the fact that there might be less risky locations doesn’t change much since you’ll then have places with higher risk, where the collection will have burned down even sooner. Even if you knew the best location with the least hazard, optimally you would still want to move all collections there anyway.
The strategy didn’t work since any strategy was likely deemed for failure due lack of funding, not because it was suboptimal.
What they did by centralizing the collection was the best thing they could do to save it, but apparently they didn't even have money to protect a single museum from fire hazard. Spread the collection around the country and you don't even have money/people for proper maintenance and protection against theft in each individual location.