News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help fund an open source Facebook alternative: Appleseed by joe_the_user on Thursday October 14, 2010 @02:37AM (#1790045)
If access is rescinded, that user loses access to view that data.

And if the user has a script that saves all the data they momentarily had access to, what happens? I mean, I'd do that since I expect continued access to any data I get. I don't think that makes me "evil".

The whole thing seem ridiculous. If you have 500 different messages for 500 different people, send them each an encrypted email and be done with it. If you're sending the same message to 500 people, the chances that you'll be able to rescind it seem negligible. I mean, for 500 people not to share a message either 1. It's very boring enough they wouldn't bother, 2. They are really tight with you somehow, 3. They're part of a very tight, well managed organization. But none of this can be controlled by software.

If a node is just supplying information transport, that is different and encryption works and is intended for that situation. But thinking there's a way to send information to your friends to read and somehow force them to keep it secret seems ten times as preposterous of earlier "trusted platform" end-to-end DRM schemes.

Am I missing something? Tell me.

Re:Help fund an open source Facebook alternative: Appleseed by michaelchisari on Thursday October 14, 2010 @09:36AM (#1790805)
And if the user has a script that saves all the data

There's no algorithm yet for how to deal with friends who are dedicated, untrustworthy jerks.

Someone out there, somewhere, is working on it, but Appleseed is focused on providing tools for users to determine how they group their friends based on trust, but if that trust is broken, there's not much that can be done (at this point), except to remove that person's access, and no longer trust them.

Re:Help fund an open source Facebook alternative: Appleseed by joe_the_user on Thursday October 14, 2010 @03:46PM (#1792304)
I don't actually think that saving an email or message or whatever makes me untrustworthy.

A scheme where one could send a message to someone and expect to be able to rescind it at any point in the future seems both unworkable and not really the way I expect people, "friends", to relate to me.

Re:Help fund an open source Facebook alternative: Appleseed by michaelchisari on Thursday October 14, 2010 @04:25PM (#1792437)
I don't actually think that saving an email or message or whatever makes me untrustworthy.

Saving it, no. Sharing it, yes.

expect to be able to rescind it at any point in the future seems both unworkable

I agree